The_Rev
Glenfarclas 12 Year
Single Malt — Highlands, Scotland
Reviewed
October 5, 2017 (edited November 8, 2019)
It's taken me a while to get to the point where I feel I can review this whisky, as it sent me on a rollercoaster ride initially. My first dram was quite pleasant and what I expected - a nutty, slightly spicy, lightly fruited dram that wore its sherry influence on its sleeve, but in that particular Glenfarclas style. It fell, as I expected, somewhere between the 10 and 15 year olds for complexity and body. My second dram was a disaster - I'm assuming either my taste buds were out of sorts, or I accidentally grabbed a dirty glass, or something, but it tasted foul and I almost didn't come back for a third dram. But I did, and then a fourth, and I'm happy to say that Dram #2 was an aberrance, nothing more. It is precisely what one comes to expect from Glenfarclas - dried fruits, nuts, a lightly smoky black tea quality (think Russian Caravan), a pinch of mint, a little something sweet from the bakery. It suffers a bit from comparison to older expressions, which simply bring greater complexity and longer finishes to the table, but it is an immensely drinkable sherried single malt priced quite favorably. For me, there's no need to bother with the 10 Year when I can buy a bottle of this for only an extra $7-10.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Good review - nice catch on the Russian Caravan tea note - never noticed it before but your comment sent me scurrying for a dram and yes, there it is! Agree completely that this suffers from being compared to the older expressions, which is a disservice.
I really admire their approach to whisky-making - they do it their way, they don't screw around with fads, they put out reliably good whisky, and they sell it at a fair price without trying to screw you out of a few extra dollars to pay for fancy packaging and marketing shenanigans. I had a lovely visit there last summer; even my non-whisky-drinking wife enjoyed herself and commented on how much she appreciated the Glenfarclas way over the Diageo model we saw a few clicks up the road at Cardhu.
Totally agree that the extra money for the 12 over the 10 is worth it. Being an independent distillery their prices are great especially for the older ones. A 25 year for $160 is not bad.