Camardicus nailed this in his review. I was thinking how I'd sum this one up and there were all the thoughts in my head :-). Can't believe this is 57% it's so drinkable. Definately my 2nd favourite Talisker and 4.25 or 4.5 rounding up for value or maybe higher I think. I'll have to compare against the 10 as I have a feeling there could be a tie here. Completely smokes the Kilchoman 10th Anniversary of similar % I had a few days ago (sadly not reviewed as I've given up on Distiller adding anything in a timely manner or at all these days)