LeeEvolved
Caol Ila 12 Year
Single Malt — Islay, Scotland
Reviewed
December 2, 2017 (edited September 7, 2019)
I originally worked my way through a bottle of this peaty, Island whisky almost 2 years ago. Thanks to my buddy Paul, I get to try this one again thanks to our distillery trading group.
Upon pouring this one into the taster I was greeted with all those things I love about peated whisky: campfire smoke, earthy peat, sea salt, freshly paved asphalt, BBQ’d meats, band aids, iodine, etc, etc...
It’s finally turning cold here in central Virginia and there’s nothing more enjoyable than a smooth, warm whisky to keep the chills at bay. The finish lingers here with a nice, zesty pop of lemon rind and slightly abrasive alcohol burn.
It’s a fantastic dram and I really need to look for a fresh bottle to keep stocked behind the bar. The price is slightly higher for an industry average aged 12 year old single malt, but at least Caol Ila hasn’t abandoned this for a tricky NAS replacement. Thanks again, Paul. I’m glad I got to experience this one again. 4 stars. Cheers.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Nothing like this one on a days that are so cold the central heating seems to make no impact. I do find though that in comparison (why do we compare things? Is it really necessary?) with Talisker 10 year and the almighty one, Lavagulin 16, the Caol Ila comes in as choice number three. But hey, given the choice I'd drink all three :)
Laphroaig 10 is my pick among the Islays around $50, but agree Caol Ila’s a good change of pace (sweeter) — great review!
Nice review. Can’t wait to tear into the remainder of my bottle
Great summary. For me this has become the benchmark basic, good, age-statement Islay malt.