Dreaming-of-Islay
Compass Box Spice Tree
Blended Malt — Scotland
Reviewed
December 22, 2017 (edited October 21, 2024)
This is the best whisky that I've tried in the last few weeks, by a fair margin. Compass Box's mid-range blends don't always do it for me -- I was not a big fan of Peat Monster, despite revering Islay scotches in general. But this is a bewitching scotch. Its aromas don't adequately herald the complexity that eventually arrives on the palate: I mainly get cherry, honey, and oak in nice balance, but not too much else. Then I take a sip and find myself struggling to identify all of the discrete flavors. There's an unexpectedly fruity entry of apricot and other fresh fruit, including both orchard and citrus varieties, an ale-like maltiness at its center, and then a whorl of spices including fennel, cinnamon, and anise. This scotch fades in a medium-length finish of anise syrup and lingering sweetness. The nose and finish don't entirely live up to the palate, but I'd recommend this to anyone who likes sweet and spicy flavors.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
... only surpassed by Flaming Heart, No Name and The General. Excellent whisky!
My favourite of the standard range CBs. I had to check my past ratings for how I've ranked them - it was 1: Spice Tree (91/100) 2: Hedonism (90/100) 3: Peat Monster (88/100) 4: Asyla, Oac Cross, and the two Great King Streets tied on (87/100)
Spot on and lovely review!
Just picked up a fifth last month, nice to see we’re still in step!
@Generously_Paul - Of the core 5, I'd go 1. Hedonism; 2. Spice Tree; 3. Asyla/Peat Monster (tie.); 5. Oak Cross (I thought that was terrible) . . . the Great King Street blends would be above Oak Cross if we're counting those too.
Definitely a good one. Of their 5 core range expressions I rank this one third behind peat monster and Hedonism