It took me a while to review this one. I wanted to really love this. Edition #1 was great. Edition #3 is amazing. There is something with Edition #2 that my palate really hates. If I had to describe it, it’s almost an astringent-type taste. It’s really strong and I cannot get over it. I’ve had drams of this on 3 occasions now. Neat, with some water, with an ice cube... it doesn’t get rid of that sharp unpleasant taste I get from this. 2.75/5