LeeEvolved
Glengoyne 12 Year
Single Malt — Highlands, Scotland
Reviewed
January 4, 2018 (edited January 5, 2018)
Well, it’s back to working my way through the Scottish Distillery Tour group samples after taking a bit of a holiday break whilst breaking open a few new bottles of my own. This time it’s Glengoyne 12 year old. This one was supplied by my friend Scott, from Long Island. It’s a Highland malt, 43% ABV and is a golden yellow in color and produces runny, oily legs in the tasting glass.
The nose is atypical of a Highland malt: caramel & toffee apple, tropical fruits, honey sweetness with a touch of charred oak barrel shining through. The palate starts out smooth, with some milk chocolate notes, that return back towards the nose with honey and vanilla. The oak is restrained here because the mouthfeel turns a bit flat. I wouldn’t call it oily, it just reminds me of a flat, soda pop type of feeling. Let’s just say it’s the opposite of lively. The dram kinda falls on its face here. It’s a shame because the nose and initial sip were solid. The finish is long and slippery, but quickly turns bitter. A very unpleasant bitter. Dammit.
Overall, this one just doesn’t cut the mustard when it comes to highland style single malts. The nose starts out promising but the palate and mouthfeel don’t deliver, while the finish really kills it with the bitterness. Thanks to @Scott_E for this sample, but I just think that you may have to climb higher into the age statement offerings here if you want to see a Glengoyne that shines. 2.75 stars. Cheers.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Yeah, no worries. I understand that not all will be winners with each of us. Always hoping that the purchase will be enjoyed. But, that what this is all about - to get opinions and feedback so we can have the best experience for our purchase.
I don't like the finish of younger Glengoyne's as well. Both 10- and 12-year-old, I would not recommend. However, I was positively surprised by Glengoyne 15 yo: that malt is much better!
@PBMichiganWolverine - hold up, I’ll put my Invergorden up against that Girvan. Lol. @Scott_E - don’t sweat it, my friend. It has contributed quite well to my growing buzz so far tonight. That’s half the battle.
I liked it @Scott_E. Don’t listen to him, it’s not even close to that Girvan
No worries Scott. Can't win them all. The prize for Most Likely to get Spat Out still belongs to the 10 yr old Girvan
Sorry you didn’t enjoy. I have never tasted a Glengoyne and coming across this when out of town and needing this for the group, snagged it. Oh well!...