PRICE: $30-45
INFO: Japanese no-age-statement blended whiskey. The reported components from biggest proportion to smallest proportion: 1) Hakushu (malt); 2) Chita (grain); and 3) Yamazaki (malt). Maturation is coming from both American white oak and Spanish oak.
NOSE: 52/100. Atrocious right off the bat. Glue and plastic. I’m not having this neat. With a few drops of water and some time, the dram settles down. Honey, straw, and granny smith apples. You get none of the floral notes that characterize Hibiki and Yamazaki.
PALATE: 44/100. Really bad grain. I find it hard to believe that Hakushu is the main component. There’s some hot, youthful barley and corn, with a harsh, nasty vanilla. There is a cologne note – like actual cologne – try spraying some cheap Calvin Klein in your mouth. I cannot believe how bad this is.
FINISH: 30/100. Sorry, I could only manage two sips – about one-tenth of my 5cL sample. I dumped the rest. It’s flat, metallic, coppery. My kryptonite when it comes to whiskey is not Sulphur or bitterness; it’s the taste of blood, like you bit your tongue; I get that disgusting association when cheap grain is used. It’s what I get here.
OVERALL: This is the Johnnie Walker Red of Japanese whiskey. Sorry to start the year on a low note, but this is one of the worst whiskies I’ve ever tried. Call me a single malt snob, I don’t care, but you cannot pay me to have this again. The world is so high on Suntory, I think they actively tried to see what they could get away with in terms of cheap production costs, and it amazes me some reviewers are still giving this a tentative green light. Spend a few extra bucks. Hibiki Harmony and Nikka Coffey Grain are still overpriced, but there is an actual effort at quality with them, and they are not offensive like Toki.
MARK: 44/100.
VALUE FOR MONEY: Fill a nicer looking bottle with rodent urine, and I’d rather spend my money there.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Ouch!
Oof. I’ll maintain minimal safe distance of this one.
@BDanner remember we are the expert of our own opinion! I like a lot of stuff the experts don’t and vise versa I’m sure.
After that review, I feel kind of bad for liking it. Granted, it's the only Japanese Whisky I've had.
@Reverend45: Where did you hear that Hibiki Japanese Harmony is being discontinued? Are they running out of casks even for NAS whiskies now?
@The_Rev I'm in the market for single rabbit urine, not that blended crap.
@LeeEvolved Bad things do taste better when properly sauced. I remember at a blind tasting of 10 Islay whiskies, I thought my Laphroaig Triple Wood was Lagavulin 25. The host was like, I'm not pouring that for you, you drunk fuck. Haha, good times.
Wait, this is only available in the US? Fellow Americans, why are we letting in shithole whiskies? 😊
Obviously, I do not have to be sad that this is not available in Europe... thanks for the heads up!
If you're in the market for rodent urine, I've got a couple of rabbits and a lot of empty bottles...
I literally just opened a bottle of this late last night. I was already properly sauced so I don’t remember what this tasted like, so I will have to revisit this bottle again later on. Maybe much, much later. Lol. Great review, but I hope it isn’t as bad to me as it was to you- I have a whole bottle to work through.
Tell us how you really feel. Lol. Thanks, I won’t waste my $$
Sounds to me like you love it and are trying to dissuade us from buying any so you can have it all to yourself.
Sounds like money grab on the hopes and prayers that just because it’s got a Japanese name on it, folks will think it’s good.