Generously_Paul
BenRiach Solstice 2nd Edition 17 Year
Single Malt — Speyside, Scotland
Reviewed
March 13, 2018 (edited December 28, 2020)
Review transfer from Barreled from January 2017.
This Benriach is the second edition of their heavily peated tawny port finished limited releases, replacing the 15 year first edition. It weighs in at 50% ABV, is non chill filtered and a natural color of amber bronze.
Big earthy peat on the nose. This is not to be confused with Islay peat, which is briny, medicinal, and tarry. This is more vegetal. Think forest vs sea side. Huge fruity notes. Red berries and dark stone fruits like plums. If you can let this sit long enough for the peat to fade there are lovely notes of sweet BBQ, oak, sweet red wines, and new leather. Very complex and I could nose it all day.
The palate was much more intense than I expected, but at 50% ABV I should have been ready for it. Slightly hot and spicy at first but it does settle down nicely. BBQ pulled pork/chicken, grilled fruits. Big peat smoke, but also wood smoke like smoldering mesquite or hickory chips, and of course oak.
The mouthfeel is a bit hot at first, but only briefly. Oily and intense. Mouthwatering initially but turns slightly dry. The finish is medium long with more sweet BBQ and peaty goodness.
I wish I would have known about this whisky when it hit the market. I would have bought 2 bottles in a heartbeat. It's a real shame that something this good is a limited release. These port finished scotches are quickly becoming my drink of choice, and it really seems to lend itself well to peated scotches, more so than non peated ones. If you happen to see a bottle somewhere, just take out your wallet, pay for it, and thank yourself later. 5 stars and a big thanks to @LeeEvolved
Cheers
Addendum: I did find a bottle and I am saving it for a special occasion. It’s a real beauty
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@LeeEvolved Its all relative I guess..haha:-). I've been concentrating on importing MoM samples which was just as well given the extra charges which now make it prohibitive. I pretty much got everything I wanted.. for now which was great :-). I don't drink enough to warrant purchasing a bottle unless it's really really good these days. it's going to take me 4 or 5 years to work through what I have even if I don't buy anything more!
@Soba45 nice willpower holding out for a whole year. Hope it doesn’t fail to meet expectations.
@Soba45 - lol, that is some serious hibernation skills. I have a box coming later next week and it’ll be my first purchases since July 10th- and I feel like I’ve been on a serious drought haha.
@Generously_Paul Finally broke my full bottle buying drought of a year and purchased this one. Looking fwd very much to cracking it open :-). The Talisker 8 year 2018 release is now in my sights as well (very hard to get so will be picking up in Australia in a few weeks) and the Benriach Moscatel 22 year. Then back to bottle buying hibernation I think.
@Soba45 do it! That’s still a great price for what you are getting here.
Great review. I can indeed get a bottle for $110USD so I think based and your review I'll pull the trigger and break my several month bottle drought.