cascode
Kilkerran 8 Year Cask Strength (56.2% ABV)
Single Malt — Campbeltown , Scotland
Reviewed
April 30, 2018 (edited June 22, 2021)
Nose: Mild, soft and almost floral smoke. Leather, sweet malt, brine, earth, seaweed/iodine, menthol, eucalyptus, deep rich but subtle soft fruit (apricot, peach, over-ripe orange). If 24 carat gold had an aroma, it would be like this. A great nose.
Palate: A spicy and smoky arrival with cracked black pepper and chili that is balanced in the development by sweet cereal and stone fruit flavours, a little vanilla, and a touch of oak. It’s an earthy palate overall, but there is sweetness as well.
Finish: Long, with smoky and sweet/salt notes, like a very mild salt licorice. Some lime zest in the finale.
A really good whisky that is very similar to the Kilkerran 12 year old expression but turns up the amplitude of everything throughout.
Being younger, there is a slight prominence to its smoky nature and the fruity, honey and vanilla characteristics that it shares with the 12 year old are not quite as developed. Altogether this gives it a more exuberantly fresh profile, but even so there is an elegance and assurance about it. However it’s not what I’d call a soft presentation - you engage with this whisky on its terms, not yours.
Bottling it at cask strength ups the ante further, adding considerable drive to the expression. For what is a fully bourbon cask matured whisky I detected only a little vanilla, so I guess refill casks were used. It’s certainly very spirit-driven.
I enjoyed this very much, but on the whole I enjoy the 12 year old 46% expression even more. Others might prefer the strength and vigour of this cask-strength version, but for me the balance in the 12 year old is perfect and more engaging.
Sampled at a Sydney whisky shop tasting, January 2018.
“Very Good” : 85/100 (4 stars)
150.0
AUD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
I'd say my sub $100 USD regulars would be: Glendronach 18, Talisker 10, Laga 16, Craigellachie 13, Yellow Spot, Redbreast 12 or 15, Laphroaig An Cuan, Springbank 15, Any decent Kilchoman that pops up, Arbdeg Uggie, Noahs Mill. If I had all that in endless supply I'd be a happy man!
@cascode - if it’s Campbeltown, you’re loving it! :)
@PBMichiganWolverine I’d certainly agree with all of those - every one is either on my top shelf or close to it. There’s a few I’d add that are just under that level of excellence but darn close - Highland Park 12, Glen Elgin 12, Hazelburn 10, Johnnie Walker Green, Compass Box Hedonism, Old Pulteney 12 spring to mind - but yes, one could live quite happily just with the “core” sublime and remarkably affordable malts.
@cascode I think there’s one thing I learned solidly from our SDT tour over the past year is that you don’t really need more than a handful of great affordable whiskies. The great timeless ones are all under $100, and that’s all that’s needed. In my book these would be : Ardbeg 10, Laphroaig 10, Lag16, Kilkerram 12, Springbank 10, Macallan classic cut, and Talisker 10. That’s it.
@PBMichiganWolverine Amen to that - all hail Frank McHardy.
@cascode the 12 is a master lesson on how to make great whisky, while keeping it affordable
Great review, and I agree about the 12 being "ready to go" without any work needing to be done. It's exquisite!