Generously_Paul
Glen Elgin 12 Year
Single Malt — Speyside, Scotland
Reviewed
May 3, 2018 (edited May 17, 2018)
Stop number 82 on the SDT is Glen Elgin. This is a little known Diageo owned Speyside distillery. I’m sure the majority of their production goes into blends but alas Wikipedia did not have this info and I didn’t bother to look any further. I’m not sure if this bottle is available in the USA because this bottle was ordered via Master of Malt by fellow tour member @Scott_E. It’s bottled at 43% ABV and being a Diageo brand I’m sure it’s colored, a yellow gold in this case, and it’s chill filtered.
The nose is very sweet with blackberry jam, raspberries, orange or tangerine marmalade. Honey, malty/buttery biscuits and blueberry muffins. Crisp green apples, slightly floral, earthy and vegetal. A few drops of water brings out more honey with some vanilla and cherries. Not a bad nose at all.
The palate unfortunately veers away as if it were driving on the road and a deer jumped out in from the car. Berry notes at first, followed by cough syrup, bitter oak, very bitter dark chocolate and bitter almonds. A little spicy and there seems to be some very underripe pineapple. Water washes out the spice and brings out a soapy note and strong floral qualities.
A light bodied mouthfeel. A bit thin but mouthwatering.
A medium length finish...bitter, bitter, bitter. Cough syrup, oak, fruits, a touch of florals and almonds.
The nose here started off so promising and never really had any problems other than maybe being a little on the light side. The palate and finish really were a disappointment. Almost none of the nose translated and the bitterness was overwhelming at times. At $46 before international shipping it’s not a terrible price, but still not one I would want to pay. Based on the nose alone I would have given at least a 3.5, based on the palate and finish it would have been at most a 2.5. So let’s call this an even 3.
Cheers
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Generously_Paul. Can emphasize. I’m actually looking forward to the bonus samples. So, going to go through those core ones first, in anticipation of the bonus ones .
@PBMichiganWolverine, yeah I’m trying to get through them as fast as I can as I have way too many samples building up from side trades. Feels like I’ll never get to them and I’m running out of bottles. The pace may slow down soon.
@Generously_Paul this round, seems like you’re plowing through?
@cascode, @KT66 I’m not a fan of Mortlach or Craigellachie or anything of that style/profile. I know I’m in the minority on those but it’s just not my cup of tea.
Strange - I'm a big fan of this one. My samples can via Cascade.
I enjoyed this very much until it got down to about the last 1/4, by which time the profile matched your description exactly. Up until then it had been much richer on the palate almost like a Hazelburn-Mortlach cross. I enjoyed it so much I bought 3 more bottles - 1 to open (which I did not long ago) and 2 to store away in case it's withdrawn at some time. The second bottle has been as good as the first so far, but I'm only a couple of inches into it.
@Rick_M it would seem I’m in the minority on the palate here. Not sure what it was, but it just didn’t jive with me.
@Generously_Paul - you can usually get a general feel for a whisky after reading all the reviews in the thread. I have no clue about this one. No two reviews are alike.