Hmmm...

It looks like we got out of sync.
Reload your page to freshen up and ensure that you get the best experience.

  • Skip to navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Join Distiller

Take your spirits journey to the next level when you create an account. Once you sign in you can...

  • Rate Bottles

  • Add Your Notes

  • Save To My Top Shelf

Create Account

Already have an account? Sign in

Enjoy our full-featured list experience in the
free distiller app

  • Create your own lists
  • Find spirits on the go
  • Easily search thousands of products
  • Follow friends and see what they're drinking
  • Track your collection with unlimited notes and bottle quantities PRO
Download Now No Thanks

Enjoy our full-featured list experience in the
free distiller app

  • Create your own lists
  • Find spirits on the go
  • Easily search thousands of products
  • Follow friends and see what they're drinking
  • Track your collection with unlimited notes and bottle quantities
    PRO

GET IT NOW:

If you want to add an image with your reviews install the app.

GET IT NOW:

Distiller.com uses cookies that are essential for us to operate the website and that are helpful for us to improve the services. By continuing to browse our website, you agree to first-party and third-party cookies being stored on your device. Learn More About Cookies
Search
Distiller Home
  • Search
  • Find People
  • Join Pro
  • Recommend
  • Articles
  • Sign In
  • Register
  • Search
  • Find People
  • About Distiller
  • The Tasting Table
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Jobs
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Home

islay_emissary

Macallan Rare Cask

Single Malt — Highlands, Scotland

Reviewed May 6, 2018 (edited October 21, 2024)
4.0
4.0 out of 5 stars
We celebrated my mother’s 96th birthday yesterday, so I’m feeling a little nostalgic. She’s a crusty, blue-blooded Yankee whose Dutch ancestors arrived in New Amsterdam (New York City) twelve generations earlier. Her father was English and her maternal grandmother was born in Edinburgh, Scotland, so I guess this is where I get my affinity for scotch. It wasn’t always this way, however, as my paternal grandfather immigrated from Italy early in the 20th century and was one hell of a winemaker. He settled in a suburb north of Boston and had a winepress forged by the town’s last blacksmith. It still sits in my 200 year old basement waiting to come out of retirement. If ever the world is annihilated by way of nuclear holocaust this winepress will be the last thing still standing. Years ago, I talked my father and a couple other family members into making wine. It was an interesting ritual that took place at the Chelsea Produce Market in Boston. The old-time Italians would only buy Zinfandel grapes from California because they had the highest sugar content. Even then, selecting the right brand required a ceremonial process equivalent to joining the Freemasons. The custom involved squeezing the clear juice from a grape and rubbing it between your fingers to test for stickiness. The stickier the better because this meant a high sugar content and, therefore, stronger wine. After an hour of arguing a selection was made and we would then move to another area where fresh, 50-gallon whiskey barrels could be purchased for 15 dollars. It was important to shake all the barrels until you could hear some whiskey sloshing around. This would insure the wood was well saturated to minimize leakage and also aid in raising the final ABV of the wine to about 17%. The only drawback to this recipe was red wine that tasted a little like Jack Daniel’s, and this is where the story finally wraps back around to the Macallan Rare Cask. Initially, I found the sherry influence of this expression overpowering. The first time I sat with this whisky I couldn’t help remembering those whiskey barrels of years ago and their effect on the wine. I know Macallan went to great lengths selecting only the top 1% of their sherry cask aged whiskies for this vatting (most first-fill), but, apparently, they did too good a job. It prompted one of my Macallan-loving friends to ask if this expression was a vatting of whisky and sherry. He didn’t like it much and I also had my reservations. Over time, however, this spirit has really grown on me, raising my rating to a solid 4 stars. Now, when I get in the mood for “heavy on the sherry,” nothing else satisfies. :)
  • cascode
  • LeeEvolved
  • deuce26
  • Soba45
  • ScotchingHard
  • PBMichiganWolverine
  • Scott_E
  • Generously_Paul
  • SolanaRoots
  • 1901
  • Dreaming-of-Islay
  • gstblack
  • AntonioSchmid
  • geologyjane
  • RussShackleford
  • Whiskey_Hound
Create Account or Sign in to comment on this review
  • PBMichiganWolverine
    September 2, 2019

    @Rick_M nice backstory. I can relate to that testing of fruits and vegetables—-coming from a south Asian heritage, my mom did similar wizardry to test.

  • islay_emissary
    September 2, 2019

    @dhsilv2 - mine was pre-batch numbers. I do have a 2017/B1 in stock that I’ll open in a year or two to see if my palate changes in that direction. Years ago I was on a sherry kick for a while. If I get an overwhelming urge to have some then I’ll spend $20 and buy a bottle. No need to spend $250 to accomplish the same goal. :)

  • dhsilv2
    September 2, 2019

    Which batch was this one? The first batch which didn't have a batch number was pretty well thought of...the ones after that less so.

  • AntonioSchmid
    August 31, 2018

    Although I disagree with you about this one, it was a great review! :)

  • islay_emissary
    May 6, 2018

    @Soba45 - thank you!

  • Soba45
    May 6, 2018

    Great story!

  • islay_emissary
    May 6, 2018

    @deuce26 - thank you!

  • islay_emissary
    May 6, 2018

    @Generously_Paul - I really debated between 3 & 4 stars on this one because I know there’s a lot of quality aged whisky in there. Hell, my favorite, Laga16, has some amount of sherry aged in it. Like @LeeEvolved said, it’s all a matter of individual tastes.

  • deuce26
    May 6, 2018

    Great story and review.

  • Generously_Paul
    May 6, 2018

    Wonderful story @Rick_M. I found the Rare Cask to be a little too sharp and cherry forward when I first opened the bottle. It took me over a year to work through it (not for lack of enjoyment, just too many samples to get through), and I found that year’s worth of oxidization made a vast improvement on the flavor. Still a huge sherry bomb, but not as sharp and it had more of the sweet syrupy goodness I like in Macallan.

  • islay_emissary
    May 6, 2018

    @Scott_E - thank you! @LeeEvolved - distiller rated this at 98. If you love a sherry bomb, this thing’s atomic! :)

  • LeeEvolved
    May 6, 2018

    Great story, Rick. It’s always interesting to see which styles of whisky float each other’s boats. I really liked the Rare and Black Rare a lot, but even I have to admit it’s probably not worth the $250+ price point. I’m glad to have tried it, but I don’t think I need to revisit it any time soon. Cheers, my friend.

  • Scott_E
    May 6, 2018

    Nice review. I love the family backdrop to the review. Always make reading them fun and relateable. Slainte.

Sign up for the Distiller Newsletter

Follow Us
Twitter
Facebook
Instagram
Download The App
To learn more about responsible consumption, please visit Foundation For Advancing Alcohol Responsibility.
  • Terms Of Service. ™/© 2026 Distiller
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Submit For Review
  • Jobs
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • About Distiller
  • The Tasting Table
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Submit For Review
  • Jobs
  • Help
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms Of Service. ™/© 2026 Distiller
Follow Us
Twitter
Facebook
Instagram
Newsletter
Sign up for the Distiller Newsletter for new bottle & feature updates
To learn more about responsible consumption, please visit Foundation For Advancing Alcohol Responsibility.