Scott_E
Macallan Rare Cask Black
Single Malt — Highlands, Scotland
Reviewed
May 13, 2018 (edited December 7, 2022)
A Mother’s Day enjoying a relaxing day with the wife. Sushi and a movie and now sitting back with a a lovely wife (and whisky).
The color is unique: cognac or brandy looking. A deep, dark amber.
Sherry rich of dark fruits and mixed nuts. Currants, dates, figs, black cherries. Molasses sweetness or dark brown sugar. There’s a touch of tanned leather or suede. In the deepest depths of the nose there a hint of dampened tobacco. The nose is one to inhale all day. Sweet and deeply rich.
The draw on the palate is initially fruity and sweet of fruit juice with spice and oak all wrapped in a medium-leight body. Cinnamon, vanilla, toffee, raisins; all rich and deep. The sweetness is not overt. A subtle non-saccharine dessert. This dram only enriches and improves with time.
A long finish that meanders between orange bitters and charcoal. Some woodiness keeps the palate slightly dry. There is a minty quality or sensation when you wait between draws.
The challenge for a whisky, in my opinion, is providing balance. Being not too sweet without being overly dry. Being peaty/smokey without dominating. This Macallan has walked the balance rather well. This is sweet but not syrupy. Fruity but not juicy...a true delight. Simply wonderful. @GenerouslyPaul, many thanks for providing the sample. This is one often not accessible to many. Thanks for the opportunity. [95/100][Tasted: 5/12/18]
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@AntonioSchmid very cool. Mine is probably either a Karyizawa edition 1 sherry or Macallan 1982 gran reserva...not sure.
@PBMichiganWolverine Linkwood 37 (1978) from the Diageo Special Releases 2016. It’s from my year of birth. I had to have it! ;-)
@AntonioSchmid which is the first?
I really hope that I find myself as impressed as all of you when I decide to crack open this beauty... This is the second most expensive bottle from my collection.
You’re very welcome. I’m going to be sad when I decide to finish this bottle and there are none left to replace it.