30 years less and at least 2 stars lower. I tried the 1973 40 year which was a lovely drop not that long ago. Wind forward 30 or so years and the result is a lot less palatable. I wouldn't go as low as a 1 as for me that is pure undrinkable crap which this isn't but there is very little going on. Very faint honey/vanilla and alcohol. 1.75 and down the sink it goes. There are somethings you should never reuse too many times - condoms and whiskey casks are great examples. This dram has violated the later example very badly.