LeeEvolved
Aberlour 18 Year Double Cask Matured
Single Malt — Highlands, Scotland
Reviewed
July 21, 2018 (edited December 13, 2021)
I had the privilege to try this 18yo Aberlour again thanks to my Long Island connection, @Scott_E. I initially had a bottle of this way back in 2016 and found it fantastic. It’s a sherry bomb that has all the rounded edges you’d expect from a quality, well-aged 18 year old. This is bottled at 43% and that’s about the perfect sweet spot IMO.
It’s amber and gold in the taster and makes lots of legs and droplets after giving it a swirl. The nose is completely caramel/toffee and sherry sweetness. There’s an underlying syrupy malty-ness that makes it dessert-like and savory from the start. The palate is warm sherry, apples and pears, light vanilla and some robust oak tannins. The finish is long and has a great lingering warmth. It’s ultra smooth and leaves melted toffee notes hanging around well after the finish. Excellent.
This is a solid 4, maybe 4.25 stars. I enjoyed this one much more than the later batches of the A’bunadh and the much simpler, 12 year. That 16 year offering is a money grab that should be totally avoided. I recently bought 2 bottles of the new Casg Annamh- which means “rare cask” and will be reviewing those in the coming weeks. Thanks again, Scott. This was a treat. Cheers.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@ScotchingHard & @LeeEvolved Yeah I agree with Lee, the 16 yo is entirely forgettable - in fact I'd say it's actually not as good as the 12 yo, and way below the 12 yo non-chillfiltered.
@Rick_M and @PBMichiganWolverine - I’ve had a couple of women over and they immediately researched for the 25-30yo bottles on the bar. Needless to say, they were shuffled out the door with haste- especially the one I picked up at the bar after she was shotgunning Jagermeister. Uh, sweetie- you gotta go...
@PBMichiganWolverine - if she still likes him after the first visit, then she’s a keeper! :)
@Rick_M I think @LeeEvolved will have some explaining to do if he gets a girlfriend. When half your apartment space is taken up whiskey, she’s sure to ask questions
@Rick_M or he’s just a big ZZ Top fan 🤷🏻♂️
@LeeEvolved - you’re always mentioning nice legs. We need to find you a new girlfriend. :)
@ScotchingHard - yeah, I’d avoid the 16. It isn’t really better than the 12, and miles behind the 18. Easy decision.
Thanks, I was considering the 16 for $80. This is $30 more, but it's the one with the solid reviews.