If 3.5 was available thats what I would rank but the sexy bottle made me go higher than lower. lol. Appearance: Darker amber, clings thick to the glass. Medium viscosity. Favorable. Nose: Oak is straightforward with some carmel and a bit of menthol Palate: Oak gives way to vanilla and more carmel. Not hugely complex but very consistant for sipping. Finish: Warm and lasting. Not hot but builds a bit. Oak comes back with a little smokiness and hint of menthol.