cascode
Midleton Very Rare Barry Crockett Legacy
Single Pot Still — Ireland
Reviewed
November 10, 2018 (edited August 27, 2019)
Nose: New-mown hay, barley, sage, rosemary, papaya, ghee, tinned fruit salad (you smell both the fruit and the tinned metal can), baked apples, green mangoes, fresh-ground coffee, pipe tobacco. After resting for a while some vanilla and surprisingly zappy, cedary oak emerges.
Palate: Creamy, herbal, earthy and deep spice arrival - almost like mango chutney and raita. Sweet at first on the front of the tongue, it gains rich, but soft, spicy tones as it moves around the mouth - ginger, orange and some honey. Hugely expressive and satisfying - it reminds me of goat tagine with mint tea on the side. There is a bright intensity that is balanced by a deep spicy warmth and a grassy cereal presence that is never far away.
Finish: Very long and lingering. The palate slowly segues into the finish and the herbal spices gradually ease away, replaced by a most refreshing sweet minty note in the aftertaste.
Immediately after pouring, the nose is unruly and unusual but with a few minutes of rest everything starts to relax and merge. It never loses its dark herbal and fruity profile however (thankfully!). Don't add water - it just turns down the volume and this one should be enjoyed at full force.
There is something about this that is uncannily like some Mortlach expressions. An earthy, meaty character that is here balanced by a very fine herbal-fruity presence. Maybe they should call it the "Beast of Midleton"?
I enjoyed this immensely and it was a great way to finish today's tasting of Irish whiskey. The only problem is its high price. For the same money I can buy truly wonderful cask-strength independently bottled Scotch whisky that, as good as this is, far eclipses it. It's an excellent whiskey, nontheless, and recommended if you have deep pockets.
"Excellent" : 88/100 (4.5 stars)
350.0
AUD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@kyle_brady Thanks! Just off the top of my head, I’d look for Talisker 25, any Balvenie Tun expression in that price range, Springbank 21, Bunnahabhain 25, Glen Elgin 18, Laphroaig 27 (that might be in a higher price bracket). There are many others I’ve missed mentioning. Any Glenfarclas Family Cask release or SMWS outturn in that price band would be pretty formidable. Many of the Adelphi and Cadenhead CS bottlings would also be contenders. None of which is to denegrate the Barry Crockett, I just tend to prefer Scottish whisky.
Great review! Out of curiosity, can you name a particular Scotch you’d buy instead of this for the same ($175-200) price?
Great review. Good to see these great pot still whiskeys alter your opinion slightly. I really rate this whiskey. The only pot still I tasted that may be better than Barry Crockett IMO could be Midleton Dair Ghaellach. But I agree fully that it does suffer on the VFM side, in comparison to Powers John's Lane say.
Good to see you are working through Ireland's finest! There are some great potstill whiskeys out there and a ton more distilleries opening up over there at the moment. Should be a bumper crop in several years :-)