BDanner
High West American Prairie Bourbon
Bourbon — (bottled in Utah), USA
Reviewed
November 29, 2018 (edited April 18, 2019)
NOTE: The blend has changed since the Distiller notes were written. Per High West's website, the MGP 75/21/4 is still listed, but the other bourbon that they list is 84/8/8 which would make it Dickel sourced. They do not divulge the source of the other components due to "contractual obligations". I doubt there is any more 13yo bourbon finding its way in here or it seems they would definitely push that. As a side-note, I appreciate the way that they are as open about their sourcing as they can be.
Batch 18019
Nose: Old oak, hay, saddle soap and leather, varnish, some orange peel and just a hint of dill in the background. High West always delivers (for me anyway) on the nose. This is a very interesting combination of notes, but I'm not sure that the combination bodes well for the palate.
Neat: Enters with a light honey sweetness followed by rye spice, black pepper and oak. Not overly complex. Bitter drying finish, similar to orange/lemon pith. Limited burn with tingly oak lingering on the palate. Some time in the glass either brings out a little more sweetness, or you palate adjusts and finds more there. I'm not sure which.
Splash: A few drops of water really brings the orange peel to the forefront of the nose. Gives the palate a pink bubble gummy sweetness. Tones down the drying astringency on the finish and makes it more pure orange/citrus and less citrus pith. A few drops of water increased my enjoyment of this one immensely and save it from a score in the 2's.
Verdict: I'm glad I tried it, but I don't see this being a repeat buy at $40. A bar local to me has ordered in a barrel of this finished in peated scotch casks (the only barrel select available in the entire state). I definitely want to give that a shot, though. I love High West's experimentations, but this on its own was just okay for me.
40.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
...any hope for this one getting better after the bottle was opened were dashed. If anything, it got worse. I'm backing this one down to a 3.
There’s a Midwinter finish as well...was a decent, nothing to pay the extra premium on it
Great Review. Agree only the Barrel finished versions are worth purchasing. Currently enjoying on finished in Rum Casks and it's a really nice drinker. The scotch finish I bet is wonderful!