LeeEvolved
Auchentoshan 21 Year
Single Malt — Lowlands, Scotland
Reviewed
December 24, 2018 (edited November 25, 2020)
I purchased this bottle from a friend who is trying to thin out his whisky collection. This “Limited Release A” bottle has been considered one of the best Lowland style whiskies in existence. It’s bottled at a rather uninspiring 43% and is deep gold in the Glencairn. It slowly formed skinny legs and left behind some tiny beads of water around the rim after a lengthy swirl and time in the glass.
The nose is typical Auchentoshan: honey and florals and not much else. It was very mellow with little to no barrel presence, either. I did get a hint of oak spice if I inhaled deeply enough, but overall, this was a shallow breather.
The palate was also extremely mellow, oaky, but smooth at first. Some light berries and vanilla were left lingering behind on the tongue. Overall, this was a pretty boring sipping experience. There is also no heat due to the low ABV.
The finish was short, lightly warming as you exhale with a bit of wood tannins and well-worn leather closing things out.
In total, this bottle was a bust. I must say, however, that I wrote most of my notes while sipping on the last dram from the bottle about a month after opening it. I don’t recall it being this boring initially- or even as I worked my way down. I simply drank through it almost as a daily dram and was content to just use it as such.
I can’t imagine it being worth the current $135+ asking price, nor the discounted $100 I paid. It’s solid, unoffending whisky that can be found elsewhere for much cheaper. The only thing you could’ve done with this bottle was brag about the age statement if you poured some for uninitiated friends or colleagues. Search elsewhere for higher quality. 2.75-3 stars.
100.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Nollaig Shona to all
Merry Christmas to all. I hope everyone got the whisky they’ve been wanting all year.
@LeeEvolved thanks so much for the advice!
@cascode - Merry Christmas, sir. Santa Tracker says he’ll be dropping off some scotch at my place in about 5 hours. I hope it’s something delicious!
@LeeEvolved Great review, as always. I’ve never been a fan of Auchentoshan so good to know I can avoid this as well. BTW - merry Christmas morning everyone, from sunny Australia :-)
@LeeEvolved Yeah I now avoid this distillery's offerings. I've tried several and this was the highest at 3.75. Starts good then fades on the aftertaste though. I have the bartender then it'll join the list of my New Year's resolution to avoid average distilleries going forward.
@deuce26 - I tried the Three Wood a few years ago and really enjoyed it, although I’ve heard it’s a bit tougher around the edges now. I absolutely loved their 25 year Wine Cask Finished bottle from 1988, but it’s going for ridiculous prices now. The Bartender’s Blend #1 NAS has some good value for the money (around $45) and I hear Batch 2 is releasing soon. Try have some solid offerings if you enjoy the lighter side of scotch whisky. Think sweet and floral.
@LeeEvolved great review. How are the other expressions? I’ve been thinking about trying the Triple Wood in particular.
@PBMichiganWolverine - yeah, I seem to recall enjoying it when I first opened the bottle, but that last 2-3oz sure seemed boring. I should’ve taken earlier/better notes I guess.
I actually liked this one, for no other reason than finally getting a pretty good Lowlander finally