LeeEvolved
Compass Box The Story of the Spaniard
Blended Malt — Scotland
Reviewed
January 8, 2019 (edited October 15, 2022)
Finally, a new addition to Compass Box Whisky’s core range. After many bespoke bottles and pricy, special releases the guys at CBW finally address the suspicious absence of a truly sherry-prominent whisky to their low cost, core range of blends.
Hedonism is a delicious grain whisky, but it doesn’t focus on sherry. Asyla, Oak Cross and Spice Tree all focus on lighter, new and ex-White oak- leaving sherry casks on the sidelines for their more limited releases. I’d say this bottle is a necessary addition, the question is- does it live up to the CBW standard of quality?
It’s named after a bespoke bottle that John Glaser did several years back for a bar in NYC called “The Spaniard”. This is an homage to that bottle and that bar. It’s bottled at 43% ABV and runs around $40usd.
It’s a rich, amber gold in the taster with watery, undefined legs and tiny beads after a spin. The nose is over-ripened vine fruits, sun dried raisins and honey. They play off one another quite well- the makings of a well-crafted, sherry bomb. After some time,however, those notes begin to fall flat and a biscuity, malt note takes over. The lack of wood or barrel really hurts here. The quick remedy is to go ahead and begin to sip- there’s no need to wait for complexity or new aromas. They won’t materialize.
The palate starts again intensely sherried: grape must, almonds and some cloyingly sweet honey attack your taste buds in a good way before turning chocolatey and a bit flat. Once again, barrel bite or character is absent and could help keep this ballerina on her toes. Sadly, it’s just not there.
The finish offers up more raisins, milk chocolate and a bit of spice. It doesn’t strike me as barrel or pepper spice, though- maybe it’s just youthful spirit rearing it’s head. There is some faint leathery notes and just a taste of wood- turning things slightly dry. I get a bit of what seems like cherry cola on the very end and it’s a welcome surprise.
Overall, the dram does some things well- there’s plenty of sherry and chocolate sweetness to keep “sherry heads” happy, but hardcore whisky folk may find it a bit too uneventful as a spirit. The price point is good, bordering on great, and I don’t have a problem bestowing praise on John Glaser and CBW for making another easily approachable and crushable blend. The only underlying negative I have after finishing a bottle is asking myself if I ever need to buy another bottle. I’m sure that’s NOT what CBW wants to hear, but that’s how I felt after the last drop. Do I need this anymore? Nah, not really.
All that said, it’s a solid pour. Maybe keep a bottle on hand for your uninitiated scotch friends and for the day you just want to pound 2-3 drams to warm up for one of CBW’s Limited Releases. 3.5-3.75 stars and maybe a bump for finally adding a sherry bomb to the core range. Cheers.
43.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@PBMichiganWolverine actually I got India, the one that I changed my mind on last minute was the American. Had it down to either Swedish or American and picked the wrong one
@Generously_Paul yeah—Sweden and India were the two tough ones
@PBMichiganWolverine I should have been 3 of 5 as I went back and forth between a couple of them but ultimately chose the wrong one. The other 2 really threw me
@PBMichiganWolverine - I actually drank through it a few weeks ago and jotted down my guesses. I got kind of sidetracked before emailing you. I need to look through my notebook and get it back to you. It’ll probably be this weekend before I can dig through it, though. Long work hours this week, but that possible snow storm should keep me locking indoors Saturday night through Monday...
@LeeEvolved you still have the Journey around the World blind sample game. @Generously_Paul was 2 out of 5. @Richard-ModernDrinking was 5 out of 5, including guessing which were double matured and ages! And @The_Rev was 2 out of 4
@Rick_M - its actually still sitting with about 10-15 remaining samples I still have piled up. I’ve kept saying I’m gonna save it till the day I’m really tuned in and only want to drink one sample. Seems lately I either want to tie on a healthy buzz or just not drink at all.
@LeeEvolved - speaking of which, did you ever get to that sample of CB Circus?
I also like the fact that CB does the entire range from something like this ( low cost, not as complex ) to their higher range limited editions ( higher cost high complexity). Something for everyone
@Rick_M - that’s a very good point. I guess I just wish CBW would lower their prices on the limited edition stuff. There’s something about spending $300 on a blend that doesn’t sit well with me. Granted, usually they aren’t duds, but $300 is still a lot of money for a blended whisky.
@LeeEvolved - the nice thing about CB; when you spend $40 with them, you know going in it’s going to be a 3 star experience. What pisses me off is spending $200 with someone else and still getting 3 stars.