malt_muser
Rhetoric 24 Year Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky (bottled in Tennessee), USA
Reviewed
January 19, 2019 (edited April 19, 2019)
45.4% abv
Mashbill: 86% corn; 8% barley; 6% rye.
Nose: OAK; toffee; vanilla; hint of dark chocolate, dark cherry & blackberry; slight clove and anise spice; did I mention oak?
Palate: OAK, very woody with some bitterness; sweetness from vanilla backed by light brown sugar; salted caramel; fairly thin viscosity and delicate mouthfeel.
Finish; medium-long and drying; cafe mocha and dark chocolate; cinnamon; vanilla; hint of dark fruit, orange and slight sourness. Oh, and oak.
Value: at $140-200 in the U.S. = hard pass.
Final thoughts: beneath the intense oakiness of this pour lies some nuance and complexity, but even the addition of water doesn’t shatter the woody bitterness quite enough, rather just enhancing the sweetness. This is a classic example of how very aged bourbon, unlike scotch, actually diminishes the quality of the experience. It’s not bad, but for the price this is a hard one to justify. While oxidization will certainly help, for the price you expect an amazing pour right away. Bottom line: there are simply too many great bourbons at half the price.
Score:
2.5/5
Hard to recommend/definitely try before you buy
150.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@PBMichiganWolverine exactly
@LeeEvolved yep, save your money for sure. Nothing to see here..move along, move along :)
@Rabbit_in_Red they’re all pretty good, maybe the ones in the 7-12yr range are standouts. There’s also a store labeled 14 yr that’s just as good as the official 15 yr at half the price. Beyond Barrell, I’d put Elijah Craig barrel proof as a close second.
@PBMichiganWolverine I’ve yet to try any but have had my eye in them. Any specific releases you recommend?
As far as sourced bourbons, I found Barrell to be top quality and great VFM ( except the 15...which is pretty expensive)
Man, most of these Orphan Barrel bottles have missed the mark IMO. Total money grab. Great review, though. Cheers.
Good revie24 yrs in casks will probably be like licking a piece of oak.