LeeEvolved
Glenlivet Code
Single Malt — Speyside, Scotland
Reviewed
January 29, 2019 (edited May 9, 2019)
Let’s get one thing out in the open from jump street: I HATE BLACK BOTTLES. Hate them, with a passion.
I also hate deception. For that reason, I’m not a fan of this whisky. WARNING: If you aren’t in the mood to read about a grown-ass man whining like your local politician at a debate over a border wall- skip this review. Still here? Cool, let’s proceed.
Glenlivet Code is this year’s mystery bottle that cons you out of $120. Glenlivet released Alpha and Cipher in 2016 & 2017, respectively. They had the same principle: don’t tell people what’s inside age-wise, cask matured-wise, finishing-wise. Nothing. Let them pay to drink it and take guesses. They even promised to tell us whats inside by the end of 2018. Guess what- they still haven’t said a word. I think they hoped we forgot to ask. Personally, I don’t care what’s inside. But, here’s what I tasted:
Glenlivet took some subpar Nadurra First Fill cask whisky, some subpar Nadurra Oloroso cask whisky and maybe some Founder’s Reserve, blended them equal parts and then added water to dilute it to 48%. Then they put it in a f#%*king BLACK BOTTLE so you couldn’t see it sitting on the shelf, slapped a $120+ price tag on it and shipped it out. Then they asked if you could decipher the Code.
(Several deep breaths later)
It’s sunset gold in the tasting glass with fat, undefined legs and appears more watery than oily. Big drops left behind.
The nose is fresh oak, vanilla and sherry infused with cinnamon and light citrus rinds. There’s some faint oak here, as well, but I think it’s tied to the peppery note rounding things out.
The palate is peppered by young and lively spirit. The sherry comes through around mid sip and mingles with apples and pears before being overpowered by spice and harsh alcohol notes. There’s no complexity, it’s just an abrasive mess.
The finish is hot and spicy but short, with some sherry sweetness lingering and fighting back the dry oak tannins and ABV astringency.
(More deep breaths)
So, in effect, I’ll take a shot and guess that this is a big ole con job by Glenlivet. This is watered down stuff that should’ve aged a little while longer and turned into something for the Nadurra line. There’s flashes of greatness, but it feels like a failure of the sum of all its parts. They tasted single casks for Nadurra and these reject casks were blended together and turned into deception. That’s what they should’ve called this...Glenlivet DECEPTION.
Buy something from the Nadurra line for $75-80 and spend the other $40 on a Compass Box blend and you’ll end up with 2 great bottles instead of 1 bad one. 2 stars with .5 star deducted for a bad price point and the stupid, black bottle.
(Put on a happy face...)
Cheers, my friends.
120.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@LeeEvolved - how did you slip this taste by me 3 months ago? The Octomore black bottles are brutal! I have a small anchor on a string I drop in there to mark twain.
@carpejugulum - thanks. If you find a link for the movement please share it here. We can’t be the only ones, lol. Cheers.
Love the way you hold back and don’t tell us how you really feel! Never too impressed with The Glenlivet. Nadurra was about the best of theirs as you say. Currently have Black Art 5.2 and an Octomore in a black bottle. It is a bit of pain not knowing how much is left. Same goes for by turquoise Laddy Islay Barley and JW Gold Bullion. Where do we sign up for the translucent bottle movement.
Epic smackdown. Definitely deception.
@LeeEvolved I appreciate these type of reviews most as it brings awareness to hokey products. This is where age statements should be the norm (again). At a bare minimum, you have some idea what your up against (vs the greenback). Or, at a minimum, if NAS are allowed, as Compass Box has been spearheading, provide some transparency. Anywho, as always Lee, nice job. I assume you took the plunge and bought a bottle.
@LeeEvolved great passionate put down! I feel worked up enough to join your anarchist anti-blackbottle group (or to sign a petition at least) 😀
Yeah I looked at that one and thought na don't think I'm missing out on much. Looks like I was right!
I find Glenlivet a pleasant bar drink but doubt I would buy any of their other offerings. Not sure why, actually.
@LeeEvolved great review as always! I didn’t realize Glenlivet had the audacity to make three of these! I had their first one (Alpha), and thought it was okay, but really despised the idea of “ give us your money, and we’ll give a bottle of of god knows what type of whisky”.
@LeeEvolved trust me I hear you! Nothing worse than dropping north of a C-Note only to be dissapionted! Also, knowing the juice level is always a must! Otherwise I kill the bottle quicker than I intend to!
@dubz480 - the only real reason I hate black bottles is that I can’t see how much whisky I have left to drink without pouring it into a glass and back into the bottle. There have been some great whiskies in black bottles: Bruichladdich’s Black Art series and Compass Box’s No Name are awesome stuff. This Code is not. I just wanted something else to bitch about lol.
The bottle did look cool though! Saw it at Costco and thought, I bet Neo likes that one! 🤣 Great review as always. I was never going to spend the $90 they wanted, but your review makes then pass that much better!