Generously_Paul
Cambus 1991 25 Year (Whiskybroker)
Single Grain — Lowlands, Scotland
Reviewed
March 8, 2019 (edited November 8, 2020)
Stop number 107 on the SDT (yes, we are firing up the tour again for a bonus round with both closed and new distilleries) is Cambus. This Lowland grain distillery closed in 1993 and ceased all activity until 2011 when it was reopened as a cooperage. I won this 25 year old at auction for $98, not a bad price at all for a 25 year old scotch. Whiskybroker is the independent bottler that released this vintage. They are a curious company that is more of a wholesaler and storage facility than an independent bottler. They buy and sell whole casks, rent out their warehouse for maturing casks for others, and occasionally bottle some of their own casks for selling. This bottle was number 88 of 555 that came from a sherry butt, cask number 62929. It was filled on 8/8/1991 and bottled on 3/8/2017, which just happens to be 2 years ago today. Bottled at cask strength of 56.9% ABV, non chill filtered and natural color of yellow gold.
The nose needs plenty of time to settle down. If you go in too quickly after pouring you get hit with harsh acetone and a vinegar-like harshness. After enough time to compose itself (10-15 minutes) there is grain alcohol (but not as harsh as most other grain scotches out there), lots of honey and some lemon zest, honeysuckle, vanilla, coconut and Honey-Nut Cheerios. Very little burn considering the high ABV. Light sherry notes, clearly a refill cask. Sherried fruits - raisins, honeyed dates, blackberries, raspberries and melon rinds. Some light ginger, nutmeg, almond meal and marzipan. Buttery, a touch sulfuric, cocoa powder and brown sugar.
Water brings out a bit more sulfur, a touch meaty. More vanilla, ginger, apples, bread. Slightly sour.
The palate starts sweet with light sherry, plenty of heat and some funk. The heat is refreshing and invigorating. Some sulfuric and buttery notes. Honey, grains, creamy vanilla and coconut. Raisins, cranberries, blackberries. Tart and sweet. Oak tannins and some harsh grain alcohol at times.
Water brings the heat way down, more juicy sherry, berries, pie crust. More honey and some fresh grainy bread.
A medium to full bodied mouthfeel that is very oily, like 5W-30 Quaker State, mouthwatering.
The finish is medium length, honey, light sherry, coconut, sourdough, grain alcohol. The finish turns harsh midway through and is easily the low point of this whisky.
This was one of the best single grain scotches I’ve had, but that’s not saying much because most of them are garbage. I tried this over several days and most of the time it was fairly enjoyable. Other times it was overly harsh and sour. Water is highly recommended, though not entirely necessary. Most of the time I went without water, but when I did add water it was better (I liked the heat at cask strength in this case). It was nice to try another ghosted distillery and a quarter century scotch for under $100 is quite a good deal. 3.5-3.75
Cheers
98.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@ContemplativeFox this was bought at auction, which can be a very hit or miss option when it comes to prices. Sometimes you can find a great deal if there isn’t a lot of traffic in a given auction lot. Single grains tend to be less desired so the prices don’t go as high as single malts, but that again is dependent on who is out there looking. Closed distilleries will fetch a higher price generally. It basically comes down to how hard you want to go after a bottle and what you feel is a reasonable price. When it comes to core range bottles you can find amazing deals at auction. I bought a GlenDronach 21 and a Dalmore 18 for roughly $100 less per bottle at auction than what I would have paid in Michigan. Of course you have to factor in the buyers premium, tariffs and shipping, but you can absolutely come out ahead in those types of purchases
Do you still find any whisky in these price ranges @Generously_Paul or are all of the deals like this gone?
Excellent tasting notes. Tragically, it seems like the most positive thing that comes up in single grain reviews is "it's much better than the rest of the garbage" though.
@SolanaRoots I’m very eager to try it considering the good reviews, scarcity of the releases and apparent integrity of the distillery for waiting until the whisky was ready and not pushing out a 3 year old dumpster fire
@Generously_Paul Nice. Really intriguing distillery, even more so after the five star review of the ‘06 winter batch by @PBMichiganWolverine
@Generously_Paul. Both are now well over $500 in retail
@SolanaRoots the 2006 winter release. The summer release was averaging like $50 more at auction so I went with my wallet.
@Generously_Paul Which bottle from Daftmill did you snag?
@Generously_Paul wow...I lost track. That combined with Lee’s makes all the new comers. Yeah...that’s SDT2
@PBMichiganWolverine I’m sending out this Cambus, Port Dundas, Littlemill and Daftmill. I’d say it’s more than just a couple pegs
@LeeEvolved wait...SDT is firing up again? I though it was just a few new pegs we were plugging ( Ardnamurchan, Kingsbarn).
Nice review. Firing the SDT up again was a great idea! If we keep the hits coming perhaps we’ll guilt @PBMichiganWolverine into opening his Brora and Rosebank. My stuff is coming soon- Ardnamurchan and Kingsbarns. I’m looking into more ghosted distilleries at each auction- if I can get a good deal I’ll pull the trigger on a few.
@Generously_Paul I think some indies are really good—-like Cadenhead, Wemyss, Gordon / Macphail. I’ve not heard of Whiskybroker though, but seems decent enough based on the review.
@PBMichiganWolverine keep in mind that both bottles were from independent bottlers and not official releases.
@Generously_Paul a 28 yr old ghosted? We need do learn a lesson from you on scoring
@PBMichiganWolverine the Port Dundas I scored is a 28 year old that only cost me $85. Hope that one outperforms this one.
$98 for a Scottish closed distillery is pretty good, especially at 25 yr. You can’t even get a 15 yr old at that price from an operating distillery