ScotchingHard
Highland Park 15 Year
Single Malt — Islands, Scotland
Reviewed
April 11, 2019 (edited June 3, 2020)
Purchased on 4/9/18. Bottle killed on 4/11/19.
Highland Park
OB
15 years old
43% ABV
Bottled 2014
Price: 90 USD
The shy middle child of Highland Park’s once respected core range, this whisky is for those who appreciate soft, subtle single malts. It’s very floral and sweet initially, but there’s a rugged maritime edge as well. Lightly spicy and lightly smoky, you will find the 15 year less bold than the precocious 12 year old; and less robust than the lovely 18 year old. A failure to stand out is probably why this was the first of the three to be discontinued. This is a fine dram, but a passive one at that. It is more refined than the 12 year old, but not necessarily better. And at almost twice the price, that’s a problem. I will make sure I have at least one of the recently discontinued bottlings of the 12 and 18 year olds stashed away, but I will pass on re-purchasing this 15.
Rating (price not factored): 85 / 100
Purchase satisfaction (price factored): 3 / 5
90.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
I found the HP 18 to be one of the more boring scotches, hope this one is better.
@1901 you need to do a parallel tasting and let us know if there is a difference and, if so, how much of a quality difference.
@ScotchingHard thanks for that. I have tried the "old" 12 and have an unopened tattooed 12. Good to hear it hasn't been discontinued but I'll keep my expectations low.
@ScotchingHard - the 18yo Viking wasn’t bad IMO. I kind of wanted to hate it but I just couldn’t. Now, is it worth the extra $15-20 price increase for an etched bottle and spiffy new packaging- oh, hell naw. But the juice is still good.
@1901 the newer versions have the tattooed bottles and the Viking stuff. I tried the new 12, and it is not good. I assume the new 18 is bad as well.
Nice review. When you say discounted do you mean replaced by repackaged versions with silly viking names, or are they being discontinued too?