BeppeCovfefe
Maker's Mark 46 French Oaked
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
July 10, 2019 (edited April 8, 2020)
The King is dead, all hail the new King.
Nose: Spices, cinnamon, clove, pumpkin, all cover the underlying brown and dank corn and wheat sugars.
Front: Big sweet honey bread sugars mix into the kitchen of baking spices, apples nutmegs and nibs tapering into a hearty caramel pecan pie slice with toffee and vanilla sugars.
Finishes with more oily cinnamon apple spices and heat, a reminder this is a 94 proof treat being sampled yet still incredibly smooth and nearly absent of any "burn" from such a stout dram. Purely delicious, seared french oak staves FTW!
Recently the interwebs have turned up a spate of whiskey channels all offering up sampled opinions, one of the more prevalent themes of the day is the Best Bourbon Under 40$ contests. For good reason Makers 46 has been nailing this contest and hard. It's continually found on the shelf at 40 or below and almost nothing in that range really compares, now the real question, what if anything outside of that range compares? I've often touted the 107 Weller Antique as "the real Weller" that's worth going after and much like standard Makers can go toe to toe with the green label Weller, the 46 may be the "new" king killer in it's ability to stand up to "the good Weller". Makers 46 is just a fantastic sampling of a top notch wheated bourbon and the kicker is you can walk into any liquor store and find it on the shelf and at a moderate price.
rating:
Just being included in the mix of top Weller products would automatically throw you into the plus 4 star category, but being an entirely acquirable product for a really modest price, that's worthy of some status as well. Most of us are value conscious when it comes to price and even those excluded from us "rabble" would do well to note the quality of this bottle. For many of us, this is in range of an every day drinker and from now on will get much more respect from myself for being a bottle that won't cause me a headache just to acquire it.
For being a relatively young(less than a century old) distillery, the folks in Loretta have not only figured it out, they've gotten it right and are keeping it coming, that's worthy of some serious kudos too. You GO Makers Mark!
Cheers
39.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@BDanner agree sir, the seared staves make a huge difference, much like the very noticeable one between green and red label Weller
@BeppeCovfefe. I will certainly defer to your comparison. You have never led me wrong. I have had the Antique once and it was very good. The 46 gets deference in my book because you can actually acquire it. What good is a fantastic bottle that's unattainable? I Remember not too long ago, Weller 12, Blanton's, Buffalo Trace, Old Rip were dusty bottles on the shelves. Times do change. Cheers Beppe!
@ Guitar_mann thoughout 2017 I acquired a few bottles of Weller 107, for a while it was my "daily drinker" so I feel somewhat qualified in making the comparison.
This is right on point. It has a lot going for it for $39.95. You can often get it on sale for ~ $4 less. Whether it compares with Weller Antique??? The problem with that comparison is, every time I try to compare the two, only the 46 shows up...
@BeppeCovfefe this has become one of my favorite bourbons. Those French oak staves give it the finish that the standard expression is missing. Definitely one of the best sub-$40’s readily available. The MM cask strength (about 110’ish) also gave the Weller 107 a sound thrashing in my last head to head tasting. The Samuels have indeed got it figured out.
@ dubz480 thanks, yea that seems to be the prevalent opinion, I have the Cask Strength on hand, will be turning in that review in the next week or so.
Great review. Best Maker's product IMO!