SolanaRoots
Journeyman Distillery Federalist 12th Organic Rye
Rye — Michigan, USA
Reviewed
July 13, 2019 (edited October 5, 2021)
Traveling down a whisk(e)y side path, I happened to acquire a bottle of Not a King Organic Rye Whiskey from Journeyman Distillery. Apparently this bottle features a throwback rye mashbill that was popular in the George Washington era. Without digging deep for facts, I’m pretty sure this is an annual February release to coincide with the Pres Day holiday.
Pouring a really nice orange-tinted color, the aroma from the glencairn is a youthful combo of rye bread, spices, and fruit notes. The palate is a heavy syrup of maraschino cherries and triaminic with some lingering pepper. While it delivers a decent rye spiciness and warmth, there’s not really any memorable qualities. I’d call it middle of the pack even though my bank of ryes to compare it to is admittedly thin. Had higher expectations.
Rating: the 91 score from Distiller is super generous as I’d lean low 80s - worth a pour but probably not a bottle. Journeyman is commendable for using quality ingredients and is one of the main craft distilleries (along with Koval & Wigle) with a stable of organic spirits. In theory, I’d like to offer my continued support but the dilemma is paying $45-$50 for an entirely average product when I can get a higher quality bottle of High West Double Rye (and a bunch of other ryes I haven’t tried) for $10-$20 less. Tough call. Cheers
Batch: 3
Bottle: 2327
45.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@PBMichiganWolverine Yep, it always comes down to quality. While commendable that these distilleries are supporting organic farmers, we all know there’s way more that impacts the whisky making process than just the raw ingredients. I will say I’m a big fan of the Benromach Organic and first pours of my new bottle of Bruichladdich The Organic 2010 are promising.
@SolanaRoots totally agree with you—-as much as I’d like to support local, organic and totally craft, it’s that premium pricing that really bothers me. And I get it...buying a bag of organic apples will be more expensive than the non-organic...same principle applies here. But the key difference is that unlike organic produce, these don’t taste better than the non-organic ones
"Due to trademark issues, Journeyman changed the name from Federalist 12th to Not a King a few years ago. I posted my review here since this is the official Distiller entry even though the info is incorrect. Hopefully @Distiller updates some day"