I think maybe I just don't like Whistlepig? Nose: Floral and grassy with some background vanilla and brown sugar, wood notes coming through as well. Flavor: Sweet and more grassy floral notes, very mild taste for a rye. Finish: Medium length with some barrel spice and oak, a little tobacco and surprisingly not very spicy. I think maybe Whistlepig is kind of boring. Like they're trying to hide the rye spice. Maybe it's just Canadian grains that are kind of mild? Sort of meh.