I recently visited my first Binny's - the Lincoln Park location in Chicago - and it's a great liquor store.  The selection is fantastic overall, and they've obviously taken a lot of time curating their craft whiskey offerings, particulary those from Chicago-area and Midwest Distillers. A few months ago, I had noticed the Oppidan Bourbon Smoke and Sea here on Distiller (thanks @PBMichiganWolverine for the add) and threw it on my BOLO (be on the lookout) list.   Oppidan is based outside of Chicago in Wheeling IL, so multiple Oppidan offerings are stocked at Binneys. The Smoke and Sea is a mix of Oppidan's Four Grain and Solera bourbons, finished in French Oak casks and oak casks that previously held Islay whiskies.  It's bottled at 46% ABV.  At $40, it was a go. With two different bourbons, four different grains, and two finishing casks, there's a lot going on.  Fortunately it all works very well together. The nose has cherry, smoke and some caramel.  It's nice, but the palate is where things really heat up.   There's more cherry, a surprising amount of peat given that all of the smoke comes from the barrels as opposed to the malt, some spice notes that are just a tad bitter but not at all unpleasant, and a milk chocolate note that is particularly strong on the finish.  There's a bit of heat, possibly a sign of youth, but the heat meshes well with the other flavors.   A note about the cherry on the palate because I found it really interesting - it's more like a cherry wood note, which I can only recall in the Corsair Triple Smoke.  The Corsair is aged partially in cherry wood, so the Oppidan is apparently getting this note elsewhere.  Regardless, I like it.  I'm really glad I included this bottle in my Binny's haul.  It's a great whiskey, unique, and at $40, the VFM is exceptional.  I plan to maintain a bottle in my collection, and I'm looking forward to future Oppidan offerings!