PBMichiganWolverine
Dalmore King Alexander III
Single Malt — Highlands, Scotland
Reviewed
October 6, 2019 (edited October 12, 2020)
After a bit of research, I quickly realized this isn’t named after the Greek conqueror Alexander the Great. I always wondered what Alexander possibly had in common with whisky. His conquests were from Greece to modern day Pakistan. Nothing to do with Scotland. Instead, much to my chagrin, this was named after King Alexander III, who gave the McKenzie clan a 12 point stag as the clan emblem, after their clan leader saved his ass from a charging stag. Generations later, in mid1800s, a descendent of that clan leader established the Dalmore distillery, and had the 12 point stag as the emblem.
Cute backstory. But let’s get to the point that really matters: this whisky, graciously given as a sample by my buddy @LeeEvolved.
A bit more research also reveals that there’s really some cask finishing gone overtime here. Normally you get one or two finishes. No, not this one...it’s 6 finishes ! Finished in Kentucky bourbon casks , Jerez Oloroso, Sicilian Marsala, Douro valley port , Cabernet savignon ( maybe France?), and Madeira ( from...guess where? Madeira!).
Despite that it’s only 40% ABV, I’m getting this biting heat on the nose. It really needs to sit a bit and calm down. Once it does, you get a mix of aromas—-from berries to caramel to floral. Palette is a step down—was really hoping that it would live up to that nose. Getting more Christmas flavors of nutmeg and oranges. Wouldn’t be a Dalmore if there were no oranges.
Fantastic experiment in casks finishing that works wonders on the nose, but really falls apart at the palette.
Thanks Lee for the pour!
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@ContemplativeFox only logical explanation is that weed was involved.
I'd be very interested to hear the logic behind the 6 can finish. I can imagine up to 4 making sense if done properly, but I don't know why Patterson thought this needed port, marsala, AND madeira, and then cabernet sauvignon in the mix too to further muddle that flavor with the oloroso.
@Scott_E that price is just plain silly. Honestly the only affordable and above average Dalmore in my opinion was the old Cigar Malt. About $50-60. The new one is a few steps down and few steps up in price
@PBMichiganWolverine Spot on. Great nose. Weak palate. All this at a cost of $175 or more.
@worldwhiskies95 I really loved the original Cigar Malt. The newer one was decent. 18 was pretty good—-but Dalmore is just priced at a premium without delivering in my opinion
Nice research :-). Sounds typical Dalmore.
I agree how Dalmores are better on the nose than in the palate. Friday I had the Dalmore Daniel Boulud Edition and I think it's the best of Dalmore I've ever tried. For me rankings are like Daniel Boulud Edition, 18, King Alexander, Portwood Reserve, 15, Cigar Malt, 12