jonwilkinson7309
Edradour SFTC Port cask 12 yr
Single Malt — Scotland
Reviewed
October 25, 2019 (edited October 26, 2019)
After some hectic business travel to start the week I arrived home on Wednesday evening in the mood for a relaxing dram, so I pulled out my tray of samples.
Edradour Ballechin Port Finish. A nice port finished Highland. While it sounded lovely, a relaxing dram this is not. Sometimes it pays to do a little research before pouring.
This whisky is PEATED. To put it in perspective: Laphroaig 10 and Arbeg 10 are peated. This whisky is PEATED. But here's the wonderful thing - as strong as the peat is, it's a beautiful, barbeque, meaty, campfire peat smoke. There's not a touch of ash or bitterness to be found.
Moving beyond the peat...Quite simply, balance is not the intent here. The peat is dialed so high that everything else is pushed into the background. The port finish does supply a nice touch of berry sweetness, but I found it difficult to identify more specific notes. In fact, had I been tasting this blind, I would have done no better than concluding it had been finished in wine barrels.
Regardless, it's an exciting whisky, and can be comfortably consumed neat. I tried adding a bit of water to see if the port notes would become more prominent, but despite toning down the peat - just slightly- the overall profile was unchanged.
The following night, I decided to break out a sample of the only other port-finished peated whisky I had on hand for comparison - Laphroaig Cairdeas 2013.
I found the peat in the Edradour to be both stronger and more enjoyable, with the Laphroaig trending more towards ash. That's not to say the Edradour is a better overall whisky; the Laphroaig is complex, balanced, and plays in a different league. But I would not have expected a Laphroaig to take second place in a peat contest with a Highlands upstart.
Thank you @PBMichiganWolverine for the awesome sample! The Edradour Ballechin Port Wood is a unique whisky experience, and one that would likely have stayed completely under my radar.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@jonwilkinson7309 after having this, and right before the tariffs went into effect, I ordered a few Edradour samples from TWE...hopefully it’ll be as interesting
@PBMichiganWolverine A very pleasant surprise! I have a few other Edradour samples waiting, the 10 and an 8 year old super tuscan finished. I'll keep my expectations in check and maybe I'll be surprised again.
@Richard-ModernDrinking Thanks for not taking the whole bottle! I'd be tempted - good stuff!
@jonwilkinson7309 this was surprisingly good...Edradour can be all over the place, but this one turned out well. It does pack a punch though; @Richard-ModernDrinking and I had this next to the Octomore 10, which was younger and more peat PPM than this one, yet this was just a brutal punch to the gut while the Octomore was more complex and graceful in the peat delivery
Glad you got to try this. I kept a few ounces of it after @PBMichiganWolverine opened the bottle at my house and it’s delicious.