Hmmm...

It looks like we got out of sync.
Reload your page to freshen up and ensure that you get the best experience.

  • Skip to navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Join Distiller

Take your spirits journey to the next level when you create an account. Once you sign in you can...

  • Rate Bottles

  • Add Your Notes

  • Save To My Top Shelf

Create Account

Already have an account? Sign in

Enjoy our full-featured list experience in the
free distiller app

  • Create your own lists
  • Find spirits on the go
  • Easily search thousands of products
  • Follow friends and see what they're drinking
  • Track your collection with unlimited notes and bottle quantities PRO
Download Now No Thanks

Enjoy our full-featured list experience in the
free distiller app

  • Create your own lists
  • Find spirits on the go
  • Easily search thousands of products
  • Follow friends and see what they're drinking
  • Track your collection with unlimited notes and bottle quantities
    PRO

GET IT NOW:

If you want to add an image to your reviews, install the app.

GET IT NOW:

Distiller.com uses cookies that are essential for us to operate the website and that are helpful for us to improve the services. By continuing to browse our website, you agree to first-party and third-party cookies being stored on your device. Learn More About Cookies
Search
Distiller Home
  • Search
  • Find People
  • Join Pro
  • Recommend
  • Articles
  • Sign In
  • Register
  • Search
  • Find People
  • About Distiller
  • The Tasting Table
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Jobs
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Home

geologyjane

Pikesville Straight Rye

Rye — Kentucky, USA

Reviewed October 26, 2019 (edited May 13, 2020)
4.0
4.0 out of 5 stars
So I checked out a new whisk(e)y spot that was recommended to me. I liked the atmosphere of the place, but most of the pours were ridiculously overpriced. Sure, there were some harder to find bottles (some Hibiki and BTAC to tempt me....) but don’t get me started on the prices (let’s just say $300 and up and we’re not talking about Port Ellen’s or Brora’s). The list of highway robberies goes on and on. $120 for a pour of Glendronach 19? $100 for Balvenie 21? $80 for a pour of Birthday Bourbon? Seriously? These were not “venti”-sized pours either. Not to be deterred, and not to turn it into an evening of settling for overpriced cocktails, I did locate a bottle of the Pikesville Straight Rye tucked away on a shelf. For the sake of brevity and in light of the setting, I will treat this more as an “impressions” tasting - how much did I enjoy the qualities I experienced, what I liked or stood out, and where does it rank compared to other things I’ve tasted, etc. Everything I’ve read recently about this rye is true - different, delicious, rich, flavorful, balanced, and pleasant. It got better as I went along - layers of flavors uncovering themselves on subsequent tastes. It doesn’t drink like 110 proof either. I would definitely pick up a bottle of this later to do a proper tasting and enjoy at home for much better VFM. This ranks right along with the other drams I’ve rated 4 stars. It may even deserve higher. I’ll update this score accordingly when I hunt down a bottle and open it up. Highly recommended, especially if you can find it for ~$40-$45 a bottle.
13.0 USD per Pour
  • islay_emissary
  • jdriip
  • Scott_E
  • 1901
  • WhiskeyFunatic
  • dmoyer
  • LouisianaLonghorn
  • jonwilkinson7309
  • SolanaRoots
  • BeppeCovfefe
  • BDanner
  • Ctrexman
  • Whiskey_Hound
  • cascode
  • Soba45
  • Whiskey_Hound
  • Ancient33w
Create Account or Sign in to comment on this review
  • geologyjane
    October 27, 2019

    @BeppeCovfefe - Agreed, this was a pleasant surprise with excellent VFM to boot.

  • geologyjane
    October 27, 2019

    @cascode - That’s painful! Is it available to you as a sample to try out first?

  • cascode
    October 27, 2019

    I'm still waiting to try this rye - in Australia a bottle sells for the equivalent of US$115, and I'm not paying that.

  • BeppeCovfefe
    October 26, 2019

    I still prefer good ole Pikers to Whistle Pig 10 year, and at half the price.

Sign up for the Distiller Newsletter

Follow Us
Twitter
Facebook
Instagram
Download The App
To learn more about responsible consumption, please visit Foundation For Advancing Alcohol Responsibility.
  • Terms Of Service. ™/© 2026 Distiller
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Submit For Review
  • Jobs
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • About Distiller
  • The Tasting Table
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Submit For Review
  • Jobs
  • Help
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms Of Service. ™/© 2026 Distiller
Follow Us
Twitter
Facebook
Instagram
Newsletter
Sign up for the Distiller Newsletter for new bottle & feature updates
To learn more about responsible consumption, please visit Foundation For Advancing Alcohol Responsibility.