bigwhitemike
Nikka Coffey Malt Whisky
Single Grain — Japan
Reviewed
January 27, 2020 (edited February 1, 2020)
Passes for a syrupy apple juice in the glass - golden wheat with a touch of oily weight. Grain-forward nose, with white pear, apple blossom, and allspice. Subdued but noticeable puff of spice.
The taste is sharp and tart, opening with mounds of orange rind plus unaged grappa, aspartame, and white pepper. A dash of walnut: equally rich and bitter. The aspartame sweetness builds while lavender, sage, and licorice arrive. The citrus, herbal notes, and aspartame continue through a pronounced puckering tingle that lingers on the finish. The tongue stays awash with synthetic orange cough syrup. It could be mistaken for a very spicy highland grain whisky (note that I am unaware of any examples of this made-up category... but it comes to mind when tasting). Despite the myriad flavors, it all feels quite cohesive and had me feeling like it was all one huge (unidentifiable) flavor through the first quarter of the glass.
The experience is unique, intriguing, and has appeal. For me, however, the positives get torpedoed by the dominant saccharine notes. The craftsmanship is unmistakable, but unfortunately I am strongly averse to most artificial sweeteners and just can't look past those flavors, which of course may not be an issue for others. Halfway through the bottle so I'm sure its not just a fleeting impression. My appreciation of this pour has improved with time, but not enough to recommend it unless those tasting notes sound right up your alley.
60.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@cascode This bottle is probably 2+ years old at thids point, so YMMV on any conclusions (not to mention my propensity to get off the map occasionally with tasting notes when im out of my wheelhouse). I did't notice many other reviews coming to the artificial sweetner conclusion, so the dominance may have been my palate for the day. I also theorized but didn't note that the sweet plus citrus oil bitterness could combine to that perception as well. Ultimately I've just never quite jived with this pour and keep coming back to that saccarine impression. I saw some of you guys having a deeper dive discussion in the past about Nikka and their potential sourcing including Scottish producers but admittedly didn't get all the details. I did find lack of definitive information on the bottle quite suspicious, although I know the teaspoon method isn't uncommon, especially not in this NAS heyday.
I didn't get the saccharine quality but hen it's a year since I tasted theis and Nikka are "going through some changes". Good review.