Zachary-Robbins
Knob Creek Single Barrel Select Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
February 1, 2020 (edited January 18, 2022)
This was a single barrel store pick by Orange County NC, and is the best bourbon I've had so far. The standard Single Barrel Select is 9 years, this barrel was 15 years and 1 month old.
I wasn't the biggest fan of Knob Creek Small Batch, this is miles better by comparison and only $13 more. I think the age completely mellows out the harsh nose and taste I got from the Small Batch. This is incredibly drinkable for 120 proof. Huge brown sugar and oak notes on the nose. Maybe some berries and caramel, but it's a brown sugar/oak bomb and you need a good nose to pick out the rest. It is sweet and delicious on the tongue. Not sickly sweet, the dessert spice and oak balances the brown sugar/caramel sweetness to perfection. I also taste more stewed dark fruits than what I smelled. Oak and alcohol are most prominent on the finish. It lingers for a long time and turns to toffee, spice, and a little tobacco or vegetal.
I saw a review on WhiskeyJug describing one of his KC SiB Select bottles as creme brulee, and I think that describes this well. It's a classic example of what I think bourbon should taste like. As a high proof/cask strength bourbon (>55%), I like it more than these I've had in the last year: Elijah Craig, Old Grand Dad, Maker's Mark, Wild Turkey, Russell's Reserve, 1792, and Old Forester. At $50 it's hard to think of a better buy when you consider how many unique single barrels you can try.
Barreled 02-11-2004, Bottled 03-11-2019, Orange County ABC Batch No. 1, Warehouse W-X, Floor F-04, Rick R-033
49.95
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@BDanner The 3 store picks I've gotten in the last year were all excellent (Elijah Craig, Knob Creek, Woodford Double Oaked), or at least his taste aligns with mine pretty well.
Nice! I've been pretty disappointed with most of my local ABC's picks. They've had two Elijah Craigs that weren't even as good as the regular Small Batch and a Russell's Reserve that is damn near undrinkable. I did enjoy their barrel of Kentucky Spirit. Sounds like you got a really good one.
@bigwhitemike Yeah I'm glad you agree. I thought I was a little simple thinking this is among the best stuff available.
In my opinion, KC SiB store picks are the best value in high proof bourbon and probably top 5 across any proof. And they are always available. They are not as complex as the very best stuff, but have a target flavor profile, nail it, and are just really incredible stuff. Much superior to the Small Batch.