Scott_E
Old Pulteney 21 Year
Single Malt — Highlands, Scotland
Reviewed
February 29, 2020 (edited July 18, 2022)
Old Pulteney 12 was one first single malts I came upon in my whisky journey and have been a top favorite of mine. Well, tonight was a good night for a pour as I am able to take my time in my solitude and really delve in. The 17 and 21 I have briefly tasted at Whiskyfest 2017. Since then I needed to have these for my own. Best of that 2017 night, for me, was this 21 year old.
The pour is a light golden amber color.
The nose begins as tropical-fruity, dark chocolate. Slowly as is opens, the briny maritime notes merge into the tropical fruits. Orange creamsicle bursts open and wonderfully dominates. It does weaken and the dance of aromas start to work together. Saw dust, vanilla custard, oatmeal raisin bread, honey and lemon hold the aroma line. The collective aromas are all soft, rounded and gentle.
First entry on the palate is ginger root prickly. After acclimation, the palate can begin to detect the flavors. Oranges, cloves, nutmeg, cinnamon, wood char provide the vibrant side. But there is a soft, sweet to counter. Butterscotch, golden honey, toasted coconut, dried pineapple and syrupy dates.
If you want your dram to be sweeter, taking the prickly nature away, add a small dash of water.
The finish is medium-long with the ginger prickle and honey that slowly fade to wood dryness with a pinch of salt. All to a deep and soul warming joy.
I am a big fan of Old Pulteney. The 12 has accompanied me on many a beach house vacation. This 21 is one to nurse slowly; savor it all. The parts and the whole. A wonderful sipper that would be perfect for a beach sunset or by a warming winter fire. I was able to snag two bottles. One for enjoying now and another for some future unknown purposeful sharing. I am glad I am able to currently enjoy as, alas, this will be soon, if not already, have gone the way of the Dodo. [96/100][$169][Tasted: 2/28/20]
169.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Congrats on 400 great reviews.
Great review @Scott_E and a noteworthy 400 milestone - congrats
Ah yes good spotting Rick. Happy 400th!
@Rick_M Yes, somewhat. Figured to make is somewhat special, lol.
@Scott_E - not a bad choice for your 400th. Trying to slip that one under the radar were you? :)
Nice review :-). I still have a bottle of the 21 yr but its promised to @cascode. If he ever no longer wants to claim it I'll bust it open and share it around one day..
@Richard-ModernDrinking mixed reviews on the new line. @cascode thought 18 was the best. Then I’ve read Huddart is very good. Very subjective series whereas the original lineup was pretty solid across the range. Will have to try if I come across.
@Scott_E I’d love to pull that out and try it—-but as I get older, I find myself losing patience...after searching the first 100 or so bottles, I give up
@Scott_E I thought the new range was decent, if not up to the heights of the 21. The 15 is the best.
@PBMichiganWolverine well, if you ever decide to pull it from your cache, save me a pour. Or even better, let’s meet up and do the comparison.
@Scott_E somewhere...in a Costco storage box, I think I have a 1974 distilled OP 26yr . That would be interesting to compare
@PBMichiganWolverine No, and I have read the same. Haven’t seen the newer releases near me. The optimist in me says they will hold the line. But I think the pessimist is winning out and the newer line will not be as good. (Moan....)
I’ve read mixed reviews of the new OP. Some say not to dismiss, others say it’s a shadow of its former self. Have you had the chance to compare the new against the old?