Zachary-Robbins
Ardbeg 10 Year
Single Malt — Islay, Scotland
Reviewed
April 7, 2020 (edited April 21, 2020)
This was the first peated single malt I've had, so I dove right into the deep end from Johnnie Walker Black to classic Islay. The first thing that took me by surprise was how light and delicate the color appears in the glass. It's something I've begun to appreciate about Islay and Island scotches, they usually don't add artificial color.
This is pure campfire, or your buddy on a charcoal grill that doesn't know how to maintain heat and flame levels. It is all ash/smoke and is delightful. What I don't get that I've seen in reviews and I've gotten with Laphroaig is a medicinal quality. This is a haphazard mixture of logs you find within 200 feet of your campsite while Laphroaig tastes more like a fire with lingering notes of accelerants like kerosene or plastic. (I hike and backpack a lot.) I also get hints of sea salt and citrus.
It is surprisingly light when it hits the tongue, but then it gets meaty and rich with smoke and brine. The ethanol and oak spice hits the back of the tongue on the finish, it is oily and long. Chewy is the best way to describe it. I don't think I have the nose or palate to detect a lot of the fruit/sweet notes, but I don't care. I'm now a gigantic fan of peated malts because of this, and I've savored this bottle for almost 9 months. The consistency over that time period is outstanding.
54.95
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@BDanner I've actually only had Laphroaig 10 and Cask Strength at a bar so I can't given an honest comparison. I don't mind the artificial smoke elements I get in Laph, just thought that was a noticeable difference.
Nice review! While I find myself more in the Laphroaig Camp (with Lagavulin as my Special Occasion Pour) this is really good and I respect the fact that they don't chill filter or add coloring. I haven't had an Islay that wasn't stellar, including the un-peated Bruichladdich Classic Laddie. Also, if you haven't tried the Port Charlotte 10, grab it if you see it.
@Ctrexman Already bought that 5 months ago, I usually review when I'm near the bottom of the bottle. It's my favorite scotch so far.
Great review. I prefer Ardbeg to Laphroaig as well though both are excellent. Check out Ardbeg oogie to take it to next level