I see the bad reviews, but I like this one. My first introduction to the Auchentoshan lineup. Nose: Initial sniff almost burned my nose, but she eventually softened. The bourbon cask is evident even if you weren't told. But behind that is the malty scent. Also some fresh fruits. Cinnamon apple and some pear. At times I also got a little pineapple. Further in there was a hint of smoke. Taste: the bourbon was not dominant, and I was glad. Sweet cereal flavors. Honey. Graham cracker. Got some kick for 40%. Finish: Finish is long. Look at the way it coats the glass and you can tell why. I actually experienced some chocolate notes like whiskey finished in Sauternes barrels. Overall: a solid whiskey. Maybe because I didn't have any preconceived notions going in. If you can find for $50... Try it. UPDATE: Day 2, this got even better. There were at times also dried apricot notes. Really surprised by this whiskey. I compared to the base Dalmore... And I like it better. Sue me! UPDATE: Day 3. Smoky!