Benji-Robert
Famous Grouse Smoky Black
Blended — Scotland
Reviewed
July 6, 2020 (edited December 11, 2020)
For being cheap the palate had a lot in common with fancier scotch. Raisin is there strongly as others note, I get more raisin bread with dried apricots after myself. The smoke isn't strong like the words 'smoky black' suggest it's justtt enough to trick you into thinking it's a lot nicer than it is--balanced, purposed, gentle, robust enough to not disappear immediately. Unfortunately it seems to be all about polish with this one as everything else specific to the N/P is so boring I'm not gonna bother much more on it
It's a touch to sweet as is to make me think it'd be good as a rusty nail base but perhaps it you like them plain with literal DROPS of drambu and no more it could work.
Small ethanol nose hint once you first pour but it goes away quickly. It takes ice OK but made it super boring. Mouth when neat was like swallowing air once it breathed nicely and got on your tongue a little. I liked that, even if the liquid wasnt remarkable much.
For those thinking budget smoky cokey, it lacks sherry depth and wasnt terribly good. It was way, way better than your usual brown is with mexican coke, however. Made me want to try root beer (called a gunslinger random fact) as it seemed more suited.
2.75/5 real taste score (enjoyable, little else)
4.25/5 on brown value scale.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
I WAS thinking budget smoky cokey! Thanks for answering that in your tasting.
@Benji-Robert very cool! In the years I’ve been on this platform I’ve enjoyed how folks develop their own rating systems. Love the creativity!
Nice review. I flogged this a bit in my review but you sum it up pretty good here
@WhiskeyLonghorn I personally tend to lump most brown liquor on roughly the same $ scale whichever side of the Atlantic it hails from to A) keep my wallet/wife happy and B) think of the flavors separately than the cost 1/5 would be something like a bad or "off" bottle of something expensive with NAS--think of the most overpriced glenlivet you've ever had 2/5 maybe the same but with a uniqueness that makes you bear the expense--think dewars double double 21y 4/5 think crown reserve 5/5 is for crazy amazing things like old grandad BIB, maybe mckenn or taylor @msrp. and the RARE scotches under $50 that blow your socks off. it's not perfect since I arbitrarily judge in the sense I'm giving them a benchmark instead of a bottom/mid/top-shelf mindset.
Lovely review. What’s your “brown value scale”?