This smells a bit more like peanut butter than Sheep Dog does. It has a hint of Reese's cup rather than just butterfinger. The palate is harsher with less subtlety. There's some richer but slightly more artificial caramel. The flavor is less complex than that of Sheep Dog, but it does taste more like actual peanut butter. There's something a bit artificial in this flavor profile though that there wasn't in Sheep Dog. I'd give slight preference to Sheep dog for drinking neat. For mixing... Uh, I'm not sure what this would be mixed with, so I'm not sure. Of Sheep Dog, 99, and this, Ram's Point tastes the richest and most like peanut butter. But. It also tastes the most artificial and sort of gross. If I had a cocktail that called for peanut butter whiskey, I'd probabaly choose this. Otherwise, I'd probably choose one of the other two. This leaves me with the dilemma of having to answer the questions "are there really cocktails calling for peanut butter whiskey?" and "would anyone ever drink one of these things neat?". Honestly, I might actually sip a small portion of Sheep Dog or 99 Peanut Butter at dessert time. This is still way better than most of those flavored vodkas, so it isn't awful, but it isn't really great. I'll give it an 8 for it's fun sweetness and richness and bump it up to a 9 for potential mixability.