dhsilv2
Belle Meade Bourbon Sherry Cask Finish
Bourbon — Indiana (bottled in Tennessee), USA
Reviewed
July 26, 2020 (edited July 30, 2020)
batch 18-12 bottle 1379
I feel perhaps we need to discuss batches on this one more and this is going to be a case of this.
Nose - sweet baby fruits and brown sugars. Sharp alcohol notes, really surprising on this, but yeah alcohol bites at 46%. Tart and tannic oak, very bitter. Those oak notes are tough to get past. Raisins and dates and all kinds of dark fruits with little sweetness are really strong here on the mid to finish of the nose. Up front no bourbon sweetness but it's there, just hard to get to.
Taste - Dry, bitter, HEAVY oak and then on the finish it transitions to more oak. Not that vanilla barrel influenced oak, but more just a dry wood plank. There's just this light fruity sherry thing that's generic and boring that then gives way to the tannins.
I'd give a more complete review but I can't get past the oak. This is one of the least enjoyable finished bourbons I have had. There is a good whisky in here, but it's been killed.
I"m at a 1 star. That said I think some batches are less oaked and you'll enjoy them. But I want to be clear, this is a different oak than over oaked old whisky. It's young oak over oaked and I like that even less.
80.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@ContemplativeFox that does sound like a huge let down. The sharpness of the alcohol and heavy tannins would ruin what I picked up and maybe I just got lucky. My experience with it was nice and mellow but at that price point I’d expect more consistency and a balanced profile.
Sorry it was such a disappointment for you. Very interesting that you describe so much oak since @Bourbon_Obsessed_Lexington 's tasting didn't mention that as a dominant flavor. You are likely right about there being considerable batch variation.