Zachary-Robbins
Wild Turkey Rare Breed Barrel Proof Rye
Rye — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
August 11, 2020 (edited May 4, 2021)
Split purchase with my brother, open since end of June. I'm slowly getting more into ryes, barely legal rye mashbills mostly because I'm not a fan of MGP ryes. This new release seemed like the perfect split with my brother since I love Wild Turkey and he loves ryes.
Big mint, black pepper, semi-sweet honey, rye spice, and ethanol on the nose. This overpowers the citrus peel and burnt caramel I get after a few sniffs. It smells a lot hotter than its proof.
Rye spice, mint, citrus peel, and black pepper are the dominant notes on the tongue. I get hints of chocolate, butterscotch, caramel, anise, nuts, and baking spices. However, the finish overwhelms the initial taste with huge oak, rye, and black pepper flavors. It is a long finish that really mutes all other notes. On the back end the lasting tingle on my tongue is mint, it really lingers.
This is a great addition to the shelves, and I think it is a solid price for a barrel proof rye. However, ever since this was released all I could think of is how this stacks up to Pikesville. Almost the exact same mashbill and proof, while Pikesville is $10 less. Personally, I enjoyed the Pikesville more because it tasted more like a high rye bourbon with stronger oak and sugary notes. Unlike Pikesville, the WT Rare Breed Rye is heavy on the mint and black pepper. It doesn't feature as much eucalyptus and licorice as MGP ryes, but it has more of those notes than I expected for a 52% rye mashbill. Still, this is a really good whiskey and I'm sure a lot of people will rate this higher than I have.
59.95
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@WhiskeyLonghorn Next time someone asks me what I've been up to and the answer is tasting whiskey, I'm going to tell them science.
@Zachary-Robbins right. For science.
@Zachary-Robbins Great idea
@runrevcollins I would suggest throwing in one of the high proof Knob Creek Ryes as well, for research of course.
@WhiskeyLonghorn I have had Pikesville and RB. Both are good but I'd love to blind flight RB, RR, and Pikesville
I am a huge WT fan but agree that while it is good, Pikesville is on par for $10 lesa
@WhiskeyLonghorn That's one I haven't had yet, I wonder how it stacks up.
@WhiskeyLonghorn RR SiB Rye and this are the two I'm most likely to get next. I just need to settle on which one. I keep hoping to see a someone blind them.
I too am trying to get more into rye after several years of avoiding MGP rye. I need to revisit Pikesville, but I absolutely adore Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel rye. That’s my special rye Barrel now.