Bourbon_Obsessed_Lexington
Garrison Brothers Cowboy Bourbon (2019 Release)
Bourbon — Texas, USA
Reviewed
October 1, 2020 (edited November 9, 2021)
Game on Texas, game on....
Whiskey night October - enjoying an evening on the porch with a friend, a fire pit, a few blind tastings and a few new bottles. All samples from a Norlan glass.
Tasting order:
Murray Hill Club, Batch 7
The Gifted Horse, Orphan Barrel
Larceny Barrel Proof, A120
Lux Row Double Barrel 12y
*Garrison Bro. Cowboy Bourbon, 2019
Saved the most intriguing for last. This thing is dressed like a grand martial and the cost of the box, pillow, small booklet (which does contain some fascinating pics of the barrel heads suggesting they are under filled and barreled at 124), leather, was, stickers and 2lb medallion... I’ll get back to the whiskey now.
Second impression - there is earth in this bottle. I did not believe the color, but it is truly mahogany and almost a deep brown and purple, so opaque that the flame of a fire pit could barely penetrate the pour. In the bottom of the bottle there was a cot of sediment so thick that I spurned a small dust tornado in the bottle with a single tilt.
Color: see above
Nose: at first pop, maybe a hint of sweet youth but that is quickly consumed with a swell of molasses, leather, raisin, smoke, hot tires, barn floor... there’s so much going on it’s hard to stay focused. What is equally amazing is the absence of ethanol at +130 proof - I can bury my nose in the glass and not a singe. Unreal.
Body: thick, heavy, slow legs, slightly tannic but minimally drying, conveys a gentle solar heat without bite
Palate: tons of dark, sweet dried fruits, molasses, tobacco, baked beans, burnt ends... honestly I once again can’t keep up
Finish: long, rich, sweet and earthy
How is this 5 years old when it drinks with the depth and complexity of a 10-15 year Kentucky bourbon?? How is it over 130 proof?? Don’t let the youth or bottle bling scare you away, the price is likely justified. Assuming as little as 10% evaporation based on barrel to bottle proof this is a blend of no more than 90 barrels and likely as few as 40 thanks to the Texas heat.
Thanks to @dubz480 for drawing my attention to this one. Still so many questions, so few regrets. I’m gonna need a toothpick.
230.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Glad to hear to like the 2020 so much @Ctrexman ! I just grabbed a bottle too and I'm looking forward to your review :)
@Ctrexman that’s the truth - everything about it makes me question what I [incorrectly] know about whiskey. Maybe we can convince Brown Forman to crank their warehouses from 75 to 115 and see what happens...
Great review. I just picked up a 2020 bottling and omfg....This is the type of bourbon that makes you reset your entire scoring system
@Anthology I think the Balmo would be a good place to start - the cowboy was great but pricy and will hopefully lat a few years
@Anthology you made some good choices. Balmo is my favorite of their lineup, and honeydew is a unique sweet treat.
@WhiskeyLonghorn @Bourbon_Obsessed_Lexington either of you tried Balmorhea or recent Honey Dew (apologies if I missed a review somewhere). I grabbed both based on distillery reputation. Just looking for some validation but tell it like it is though, if you have tasted.