ContemplativeFox
Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
October 4, 2020 (edited October 6, 2020)
Rating: 15/23
I don't think that this is as excellent as I once did, but as a $20 bourbon (if you buy the handle), it's a good choice.
N: Rich, woody, nutty, spicy, a bit oily. A very nice nose. There's some tartness and vanilla, but nothing too strong here. This smells decently old, though certainly not the 12 years that it used to be. I really enjoy this nose, moreso than I do that of Wild Turkey 101, which would be my other choice in the $20 range.
P: Vanilla, caramel, spices (especially cinnamon), nuttiness, rich wood. This is a decadent palate. I'm quite impressed by this as a $20 bourbon. It isn't all that complex and the wood does show a bit much, leaving a hint of a used teabag flavor a times, but it's still a very enjoyable palate. Some air in the glass really does wonders for this too.
F: The vanilla, cinnamon, and spices all really linger here. The heat does too, but it doesn't leave me with a sense of alcohol. It's quite a nice finish.
This particular tasting actually surprised me. Side by side with Wild Turkey 101, I have to say that this came out on top. It didn't come out on top by a wide margin, but it did win. I don't think that it quite reaches the level of 1792 Single Barrel, though the two are closer than I'd expected. Russell's Reserve 10, on the other hand, is clearly superior to this, despite being lighter, due to its nicer balance and complexity.
I started this tasting expecting to be pinning a 14 to this, but I'm now leaning toward a 15. Either way, it's a steal if you buy the handle.
20.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@jonwilkinson7309 I think reasonable people can debate the rich banana and soft sweetness of 1792 Full Proof versus the rich wood and spice of Elijah Craig Barrel Proof. I’d personally lean toward the EC, but it also costs about $10 more up here. For less than either of them, I might have a slight preference for Wild Turkey Rare Breed, but that may have a fair amount to do with how much my bottle was able to oxidize. 1792 Single Barrel beats Elijah Craig Small Batch (IMHO), but for less money you could probably find a barrel pick EC that is even better. I’m not a big fan of wheaters though, so YMMV.
Great review, and I'm also a big fan of the RR10, although I haven't had the 1792. How do you think the 1792 compares to some of the EC barrel proof batches?