Up front: Like many people, Lagavulin 16 and Distiller's Edition are two of my favorites. So I was excited to do a head-to-head tasting between those two and the Offerman 11. Unbelievably, everyone I was with scored the Offerman 11 as our favorite. It is Lagavulin+ and has an amazing balance of sweet, savory and smoky. It is highly underrated, and if you can get a bottle, grab it while you can. You won't be disappointed!