dhsilv2
Belle Meade Cask Strength Reserve Bourbon
Bourbon — Indiana (bottled in Tennessee), USA
Reviewed
October 21, 2020 (edited October 27, 2020)
Re-review this time with batch 20-01 and it came out before the new 108.7 standard which was belle meade accepting they were putting out an inconsistent product!
Nose - So there's a bit of a fruity and yet dry and not sweet element to the nose. Earthy oak notes are balanced with alcohol and bourbon in a really nice neutral level. That said the nose is really enjoyable. It's this caramelized sugar that means a dusty barn with some clean hay and some pastry crust with a really nice touch of savory on an otherwise sweet dram. Balanced in a way that's rare with single malts or bourbons.
Taste - This is such a classic bourbon. The nose leads me to expect something a bit out there and MGP can be just that. This isn't at all. It's a rush of vanilla and caramel with an ever so slight rye spice and then just wonderfully balanced oak coming in to bring things together. The rye here is playing so wonderfully well with this creamy Sweet vanilla. Where buffalo trace is the definition of a classic bourbon if you're into 100 or less proof stuff, this is classic bourbon at 112 proof with a rye kick for connoisseurs. Medium finish. Slight funky elements and maybe the most vanilla forward CS whisky I can recall.
I'm feeling generous as heck and want to go 3.0, but my rational self will stay 2.75. This batch at about 70 is an easy as hell buy. Heck get 2. These sell fast here but they're not impossible to get or even that hard, I've seen multiple bottles at multiple stores. Oh well, I'm just glad it means I can find better bourbon while other chase blantons for their cute little polo topper.
67.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@anthology same way glenfarklas does their 105. Blend it to the proof you want. Obviously the 108 has to be above the top proof barrels they're getting which if I'm to believe them and I guess I do, that means they're landing some great barrels as low proof MGP barrels are the stuff of legends.
@dhsilv2 Wait how can a distillery have a “standard” cask strength? That doesn’t make sense at all. Unless somehow they have a deal with the whiskey angels to exactly grab the same exact share EVERY time, plus also basically statically fixing all the other variables that can affect the proof coming straight out of the barrel. Ummm #Impossible. What am I missing?
@ContemplativeFox check my last review of this one, I'm nealry possative I listed the batch. It wasn't terrible but yeah it was a pass.
Oof, any particular ones you know to avoid @dhsilv2 ?
@ContemplativeFox there were some bad batches so I am ok with it.
Thanks for the tip about Belle Meade switching to a standard proof for the reserve! I'm kind of disappointed because I appreciate some batch variation and it seems kind of lame that they're dropping the proof so low. I'm sure the juice is still good though :)
Anytime I can't believe anyone questions sourced whisky, there's more quality coming from sourced bottles than from the major distilleries. Then again, MGP just remains easily the best distillery in the states.
Great review. I am a fan of the Belle Meade line. It shows how sourced whiskey can be really good in the right hands.