Jan-Case
Benriach The Smoky Ten
Single Malt — Speyside, Scotland
Reviewed
October 30, 2020 (edited March 3, 2022)
This is the new evolution to its predecessor Curiositas, which is one of my favorite whiskies. That old version is discontinued now and so I’m hoping for this freshly opened bottle to fill its shoes properly.
The nose is fresher then the Curiositas but has the same backbone. Next to vanilla and citrus notes with malty sugars and that familiar peat there also is some peppermint and roasted wheat bread. It is even smoother on the nose and has some more oak wood alongside. The nose is actually a bid better than the Curiositas. Later you get pineapple and sugared and cooked orchard fruits.
The palate also a step up. Nice. Vibrant and rich with a slightly hotter but appropriate alcoholic burn. Not as sweet but still very much like burned caramel. The peat still very bright and not ashy at all.
The finish isn’t as good but still nice. It is shorter and smoother than the Curiositas. The taste that remains is a bid like coka cola spices and equally sour sweet.
A nice replacement for the Curiositas for sure - I miss nothing - I even prefer this new expression. Well done. For this price a really good pick.
39.0
EUR
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@1901 it is the newer old because of the rum finish. Rachel Berrie said the Smoky Ten is the more refined and richer version of the new 2018 Curiositas.
@Ctrexman ha yes, all very confusing. They replaced Curiositas with this but before they did so they apparently also tweaked the Curiositas formula while it was still called Curiositas. So a bit like for OP12 the question is whether it is the old old or the newer old 😄
@1901 well after reading this I think I have the old version
Wow, that's great to hear! Replacements are usually a step down unfortunately, so It's nice to see one buck the trend now and then :)