Did a heads up blind taste with the father in law today Appleton 21 vs eldorado 21 both great in their own way but the 21 year Appleton was thicker more oily richer. Made the el dorado taste thin but eldorado has many notes to it eldorado had less flavours but was richer on the flavours it had. We chose Appleton but the eldorado is $50 less here and more complex tough call