I give it a 5 because it’s just so unique and lovely. The scent is interesting, it’s salty and sweet, creamy, cheesy, and delicious. It’s not quite funky but it’s balanced and delicious. Peat and smoke are there but they are not in the forefront. As time goes, the creamy sweet dessert comes through. The taste is also complex and fun, I taste both sweet and salty, and elegantly peaty and meaty. I think this is a very delicious whisky to be enjoyed with a meal. For those who like meat dishes and creamy desserts, you can get both in the same bottle. Such unique flavor. Wonderful find!