Jan-Case
Glen Elgin 12 Year
Single Malt — Speyside, Scotland
Reviewed
December 11, 2020 (edited April 27, 2022)
(Vita Dulcis Advent Calendar 11/24)
A very standard whisky again. Fruit, florals and perfume with a bid of honey and vanilla like - well - hundreds of others.
After revealing this blindly tasted sample I didn’t even finish the 2cl dram. I just don’t like this kind of whisky. I instead poured myself a dram of the Highland Park 18 to compensate for the less than mediocre samples I had over the last tastes. (Except for the Tomatin and Benromach of course)
I haven’t had any of the more regular basic whiskies lately and going through this Advent Calendar I know exactly why.
Honestly most of these whiskies I had during this “tasting experience” are just boring. The majority so far are super young or NAS bottlings that were only matured in ex-bourbon casks - most of them feeling 2nd or 3rd fill really.
These are not bad - they are just so one sided and boring. Yes I am a peat-head but equally like exotic cask maturations or really interesting sherry finishes that breathe life and character into a whisky. But I really wonder how anyone would enjoy these ones here or even buy this kind of whisky.
I personally just can’t appreciate them for what they are. I have respect for the art and the craft but this is whisky I wouldn’t buy or recommend ever since there is just so much better bottles out there.
Disclaimer: I will stop posting tastes of these Advent Calendar samples unless I get something that is in the 3,25+ range and actually worth spending time on. In the end this calendar was a gift so I can’t really complain and it still helps to broaden your horizon and to appreciate really good whisky.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
The last time I tasted this whisky was 4 years ago when I reviewed it here and gave it quite a high rating. It seems to have been scoring worse and worse over time which is a pity, as this used to be a delightful, soft dram.
@ContemplativeFox it’s a good practice. At times I’ll taste a bottom shelf blend (some good, some not so much) just to baseline my tastebuds. I think these advent calendars are not meant for malt heads @Jan-Case 😀
I always find sampling other stuff that's considered baseline is great for tuning my palate :) Sorry the whiskies haven't been the most fun though. It's been helpful to read your tastings though!