pkingmartin
Macallan M
Single Malt — Highlands, Scotland
Reviewed
December 15, 2020 (edited July 18, 2023)
First off, let’s get to the elephant in the room of why the hell anyone would pay thousands of dollars for a bottle of whiskey. Well, my brother and I were caught up in the idea of whiskey as an investment seeing bottles blow up in value and decided we could get into it, and where better to go than the good brand of Macallan. We bought this bottle together for the hefty price of 4500, 2250 split evenly, in hopes it would rocket up like the rest of the Macallan series we’ve seen, but alas our hopes were not rewarded here, with Macallan deciding after the first release to make this an ongoing release every year. So what does any good investor do when things go bad and the investment is worth the same as you initially paid for it many years later, but crack the thing open, shed your tears, and drink up the liquid.
Before we get to the liquid inside, this whiskey comes in a giant magician’s box with mirrors all around it to apparently show off the liquid inside and there is even a handy little drawer under the bottle that will unveil the decanter’s actual crystal stopper for when you do open the bottle, after you remove the silver-topped cork with which it was bottled. The bottle itself is a Lalique crystal decanter with six facets to reflect the Macallan’s six pillars that weighs a lot and will be perfect to club over any burglars head if necessary.
Now to the liquid: on the nose you are greeted with very old oak, think stepping into a fancy wood furniture store with polished oak, leather, ginger, cinnamon, slight hint of peat, dark chocolate and rich ripe dark fruits of fig, cherry and plum. The taste is extremely viscous and similar to a tawny port wine, but not as sweet. It feels almost like a dark maple syrup on the tongue with loads of cherries, plums, raisins, dark chocolate, and cinnamon, light peat and wraps around your tongue with that old oak coming close to an over-steeped black tea that sometimes overpowers really old whiskey, but in this case fades away right before the finish leaves you with a dark cherry, figgy pudding, dark chocolate, and old polished oak finish that lingers for minutes.
Is this a bottle that I would recommend to anyone, no. This thing is probably meant to be a trophy or for the very rich. This is an unbelievable whiskey, but that price is also unbelievably insane. As for the trophy decanter and magic box, my brother has those at his place and keeps the decanter filled with something more fitting in our price range of Wild Turkey 101.
4500.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@pkingmartin Oh yeah, I forgot about the dividends you recieve by charging fools $300 for a pour of Wild Turkey XD
@WhiskyWitch there still is. We could sell the magicians box and decanter for over 1200, but after giving WT101 a nice mansion to live in, it seems rather cruel to take its home away now.
I'm no Wall Street shark, but I feel like there was another option where you could have gotten *some* of your money back? 🤷
@CKarmios I’d say closest was a 40 year old Glenrothes that’s also sherry matured.
@CKarmios i’d say Glendronach...same heavy Sherry style.
Love the idea of serving WT out of that decanter. What’s the closest other whisky you tasted to M, do you think?
@pkingmartin Haha I would love to see how many people taste the WT and think that it's Macallan 😂
LOL - I can't wait for the101 reviews from the decanter.
@dhsilv2 I agree, I often feel the same. This was my foray into whiskey as an investment that ended with a consuming a great whiskey and even better way to let people blind taste and say WT 101 is the best whiskey they ever had after a pour from the M decanter.
To be honest, I'm kinda happy anytime "investors" lose on whisky. That said glad we got a review of this crazy bottle.
Likewise——sorry to hear it didn’t pan out. But look at the bright side—-if a stock investment went bust, you couldn’t have drank it...
Dang, sorry your investment didn't work out :( I appreciate having your tasting of this up on Distiller though! Also, having a bottle of Macallan M filled with WT 101 - IMHO possibly the best whiskey for <$20 - just tickles me haha!