LouisianaLonghorn
Belle Meade Bourbon Sherry Cask Finish
Bourbon — Indiana (bottled in Tennessee), USA
Reviewed
December 20, 2020 (edited July 28, 2021)
It's that time again. That magical time of year when all the "Best Whiskey of the Year" lists come out. I've been searching around and found that most of these lists consist of highly aged Scotch and limited release or allocated Bourbon, and while I'm sure these drams are delicious, the fact remains that most of us will likely never taste most of these, so over the next five days, I present to you this longhorn's humble top 5 whiskies of 2020.
Most of us could agree that this was not our best year. However, all the time spent at home resulted in expanded imbibing of our favorite brown beverage. This is the criteria for my list: (1) The whiskey has to be readily available on store shelves. No special releases. This means the most excellent Wild Turkey Masters Keep expressions I tried and rated this year are out, though you should feel confident to buy on sight. (2) Every dram on my list is $80 or less. Everyone should be able to taste great whiskey, and yes, I realize my definition of "great" might be different than others, but that's the fun of what we all do here, and (3) I had to have tasted it in 2020. None of the whiskies on my list were released this year, but this year is when I finally got around to them.
Coming in at #3 is perhaps the most unique entrant on my list this year. Once derided, MGP juice is now sought after product in its well-aged format, which seems to hit its stride around 9-11 years. Some of these "craft" startups that build a line around MGP product are starting to come into their own, either by aging the juice further, doing unique cask finishes, or in the case of this bottle, both. I wanted to included the Wild Turkey Masters Keep Revival on this list, but it violates my rule of no special releases. This bottle is still readily available and checks all the right boxes for a finished bourbon. Finishing a bourbon in sherry casks is different than finishing a Scotch/Irish/Japanese whisky in a sherry cask. The latter tends to be dominated with the sherry, making it a much more sherry-forward experience. Because bourbon is a...feistier spirit shall we say, I want the sherry to complement and envelop the bourbon, not mask its inherent spicy, caramel flavors. This bottle achieves this splendidly, with a oaky, spicy, mature MGP bourbon wrapped in a fruity, jammy sherry blanket. If you're not careful, you'll find yourself with an empty bottle faster than you'd like. At around $80 depending on your market, this is the most expensive bottle on my list this year. If that's a bit steep for your budget, may I also recommend the equally excellent Belle Meade Cask Strength Reserve for about $20 less depending on your market. Cheers!
80.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@LiquorLonghorn I was lucky enough to try this being 105 proof.. It was a special release and It was arguably the best bourbon I have had!
@WhiskeyLonghorn Thanks, and I completely agree with the point about MGP stock. I’m glad that I’ll at least be drinking the same version others are reviewing highly.
@ctbeck11 I had a NAS bottle. Originally they were using 9-11 year old MGP, but is suspect that well aged MGP stock is becoming rarer and prohibitively expensive for a lot of non distilling producers.
@WhiskeyLonghorn I recently purchased a bottle of this, based on the glowing reviews, but haven’t tried it yet. I noticed the bottle I purchased doesn’t have the 9 year age statement. I can’t seem to track down when this become NAS, but I’m wondering whether your review is based on this or the age stated version? Or if anyone has compared both versions and has an opinion about whether the quality dropped after the change?
Cant agree more I luvvvv this bourbon
I’ve heard some great things about the special cask finished bourbons from Nelson Green Brier. This review is just another point in the pro column nudging me to seek/pull this one out from the pile. Review go. Moving on to #2
@Cornmuse thanks! I'm looking forward to cracking into the Belle Meade CS Reserve in the new year!
@jonwilkinson7309 thanks! I like trying the unicorns like anyone, but as I get older, I get wearier of the lists full of BTAC and 25+ year age statements. I figure that folks on Distiller want to know what's tasty and they can find at their local shop.
One of my all-time favorite finished whiskeys and absolutely a worthy entry on your top five list. Great work!
Love the criteria - unicorns (and anything $80+) should be exceptional, but <$80 is a competitive market. And l fully agree on the selection here - the sherry finish is my favorite finished Belle Meade.