ctbeck11
Glen Scotia 15 Year
Single Malt — Campbeltown, Scotland
Reviewed
July 12, 2021 (edited February 19, 2023)
Nose - salted caramel, vanilla, charred orange, apple, white wine, milk chocolate, cereal grain, honey, white pepper, nutmeg, lemon, sweet floral notes, mild to moderate ethanol burn.
Taste - lemon and orange zest, salted caramel, vanilla cream, yeast, chili pepper, floral and herbal notes, subtle smoke, toasted banana, cocoa, cinnamon, clove, sour apple, mild to moderate alcohol bite, finishing medium length with citrus zest, cocoa, and herbal flavors.
I love Campbeltown whiskies, or rather I love Springbank, which is the only Campbeltown distillery I’ve experienced. Let’s see what the rest of the region has to offer. Right off the bat, I know I won’t like this as much as its 15 year old Springbank counterpart. The nose hits with salted caramel, chocolate, honey, and a double dose of citrus. The palate holds some toasted banana, a nontrivial amount of graininess, sour apple, and more of those strong citrus notes.
This is good whisky, but it’s not great whisky. There are some nice aromas and flavors, but for 15 years old, there’s more grain character than I’d like and it’s generally too sour to deserve a higher rating from me. I look forward to tasting different Glen Scotia expressions, but I won’t be buying another bottle of this at the $100 I paid. However, it appears that this can be had for cheaper, so at $70 it may be worth pulling the trigger.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@PBMichiganWolverine Yep, that and the 8 year cask strengths are on my radar.
@cascode Funny you mention Victoriana. I was just doing some research on that one. It’s at the top of the list of Glen Scotias for me to try.
@ctbeck11 kilkerran 12 is a must try. When it first came out, I had a pour. Immediately went out and got 2 bottles. Was only $60 then…not sure if it’s creeped up now
I've never thought there was any sort of particular "Campbeltown" character. Springbank and Glen Scotia have some things in common, but no more than you would expect from random chance. Springbank and Glengyle certainly have a similarity, but it's hardly surprising - I'd be amazed if they didn't. As for Glen Scotia, the best expressions I've had by far are from independent bottlers, although I didn't mind this 15 year old, but yeah - 3.5 stars sounds right. Try Victoriana if you can, it is head and shoulders the best OB Glen Scotia and a very good whisky in any comparison.
@ContemplativeFox I’ve yet to give Kilkerran a try. Will need to prioritize picking up a couple of those.
I similarly love Campbell town because I love spring bank. I was not super impressed by Glen Scotia.